TRANSCRIPTEnglish

Out-of-Touch Carney CAUGHT on Camera - Laughs About Lost Jobs

18m 18s2,987 words459 segmentsEnglish

FULL TRANSCRIPT

0:00

Honestly, Canadian Liberal Nation, I

0:02

don't know how you can support this

0:04

prime minister any longer with this

0:07

display of absolutely disgusting, snotty

0:10

elitism. Take a look.

0:13

>> Well, boy, the dinners at Basil were I

0:15

mean, they were crazy,

0:17

right?

0:21

>> Very good wine.

0:23

>> Yeah.

0:24

>> Go on, tell the story. Tell it.

0:26

>> H I Well, okay. This is a long time ago.

0:28

Uh, in fact, it was um two weeks into

0:33

the job uh at at Governor of the Bank

0:35

Canada. It's uh February 2008. Uh and I

0:38

go there and Bear Sterns is collapsing.

0:41

Seemed like a big deal at the time. In

0:42

retrospect, it was like that was nothing

0:43

but it was a big deal. Uh and uh we had

0:47

to decide because Asia, you know,

0:48

typical Asia was going to open and so we

0:50

go to this dinner and it's called the

0:52

G10 central banks. Uh so it's the core

0:55

group of central banks and JeanClaude is

0:57

the chair. We show up and we have an

0:59

hour and a half to make a decision about

1:01

flooding the system with liquidity or

1:03

shutting certain things down, etc. It's

1:05

pretty complex, but we're around this

1:07

dinner table. It's like a seven course

1:08

meal. And um and Trice spends the first

1:13

10 minutes. He welcomes me, which I

1:14

thought was nice. Mark, welcome. And

1:16

then he says, "We have the best wine in

1:18

Europe at this dinner." And since it's

1:21

the best wine in Europe, it's the best

1:22

wine in the world. And then he goes

1:23

through the wines. He describes all the

1:26

wines, you know, tick tick tick. And

1:28

he's like, "We'll have this one, but you

1:29

know, the pino grab." And I'm like, and

1:31

then he finishes it and he says, "Okay,

1:34

listen. We have uh we only have we have

1:37

an hour."

1:39

And he says, "Okay, we have to decide,

1:42

you know, we have to decide because the

1:43

politicians, you know, the politicians

1:44

are useless, basically, as he says, and

1:46

if we don't decide here, all is lost.

1:49

Ben, what should we do?" Anyways, an

1:51

hour later, all I remember is I'm like,

1:53

"Yeah, the wine is fantastic.

1:55

How much how much are we on the hook

1:57

for?" But anyways, we've got it done.

1:59

So, yeah, the central bankers have a lot

2:02

more fun and the polit We're working all

2:04

the time. No fun. No restaurant. No

2:06

restaurant.

2:07

>> Absolutely disrespectful and

2:10

unbelievably insensitive. There is

2:13

something deeply wrong happening in

2:15

Canada right now and with that prime

2:17

minister. And there are millions of

2:19

Canadians sitting here right now

2:21

watching this going, "We're struggling

2:23

to afford our groceries. We're

2:25

struggling to pay our mortgage or our

2:27

rent. We are using food banks and

2:30

standing in lines across this country

2:33

seeing record demand for all of this

2:36

because it's not going well for us." And

2:39

our prime minister is halfway around the

2:41

world yet again, laughing about

2:43

expensive wine, dropping the f-bomb, no

2:46

less, and reminiscing about seven course

2:49

dinners with the world's most powerful

2:51

elite bankers. And our media is laughing

2:54

along with him. They're treating this

2:57

story like a charming personality

2:59

moment. He was a little more

3:00

light-hearted than usual. How cute is

3:03

this prime minister? like it's somehow

3:06

relatable to the average everyday

3:08

Canadian who's buying $10 wine, not

3:11

thousand wine. But let me ask you

3:13

something. When was the last time you

3:15

sat down for a seven course dinner with

3:18

the best wine in Europe while deciding

3:20

the fate of the global economy? That's

3:23

what I thought. So today on Tapped

3:25

Maple, we're going to absolutely

3:28

destroy, dismantle, and obliterate

3:30

exactly what happened here in this

3:32

tonedeaf performance that I can't even

3:35

provide words for. Why the media is

3:37

pretending it's harmless as well. And

3:39

why this moment perfectly captures

3:41

everything that's wrong with Canada's

3:43

political elite right now. Let's get

3:45

started. Let's tap into the truth.

3:48

>> Welcome to Bakes on Things.

3:54

Welcome back to Bakes on Things. Tap the

3:56

maple for your Thursday morning and I've

3:58

got a lot to say about this one. Canada

4:00

is in the middle of the worst

4:01

affordability crisis we have seen in

4:04

decades. Housing costs have exploded.

4:07

Groceries have skyrocketed. Interest

4:09

rates crushed families who bought homes

4:11

in good faith. Young Canadians are

4:14

delaying their families. Seniors are

4:17

going back to work. People with

4:18

disabilities are trying to take side

4:20

hustles and hope it doesn't get clawed

4:22

back. Middle class families are quietly

4:25

racking up credit card debt just to keep

4:27

up with the basics. Food bank usage is

4:30

beyond control right now in this

4:32

country. Not just in Toronto, not just

4:36

in Vancouver. It's not a big city story

4:38

anymore. It's everywhere across this

4:41

country. And yet here we have a prime

4:44

minister of Canada sitting in Sydney,

4:48

Australia at a think tank event of his

4:51

friends again laughing about seven

4:53

course dinners with central bankers in

4:56

Basil. Talking about the best wine

5:00

Europe has to offer, dropping the fbomb

5:03

casually as a leader of a country while

5:06

joking about how long it took someone to

5:08

explain the wine list to him. And the

5:12

room laughed. They chuckled. Hardy har.

5:14

That's hilarious. Of course, they

5:16

laughed because they're just like him.

5:18

That room was filled with the exact same

5:21

global elite class that lives in the

5:23

same bubble as Mark Carney. But the

5:25

average Canadian watching this, despite

5:28

the people in the media who are trying

5:29

to promote it as a light-hearted moment,

5:32

well, I I would imagine you weren't

5:33

laughing very much. I imagine you were

5:36

probably wondering how someone this

5:37

disconnected from everyday life ended up

5:40

running an entire country. Well, you

5:42

have the liberal supporters in this

5:44

country to thank for that. And what you

5:46

saw in that story wasn't just a joke

5:48

being made by Mark Carney. It was a

5:50

window into how Mark Carney actually

5:53

sees the world around him. Remember who

5:56

he is, my friends. He is part of the

5:59

elite across this planet. He's not a

6:01

career politician who worked his way

6:03

through local politics. He's a global

6:06

central banker who has been spoonfed his

6:08

entire life and has never known how to

6:11

pinch two pennies together. He's been

6:13

with the Bank of Canada. He's been with

6:15

the Bank of England and Davos, the World

6:17

Economic Forum. His professional life

6:19

has been spent in rooms filled with

6:22

finance ministers, billionaires, and

6:24

central bankers discussing the global

6:26

economy over expensive dinners and

6:29

having to choose from an effing wine

6:32

list. Oh, what a terrible experience.

6:34

That's the environment he's comfortable

6:37

in. Seven course meals, private

6:40

conversations with world leaders, closed

6:43

door discussions about global markets.

6:46

And the problem with that? Well, that

6:48

environment looks nothing like the lives

6:50

that you and I lead. That looks nothing

6:53

like the lives of the people he is

6:56

charged with governing. When Canadians

6:59

talk about affordability, they're

7:00

talking about their own rent, their

7:02

groceries, their gas, their insurance,

7:05

their daycare costs. When Mark Carney

7:07

talks about economic crisis, he

7:09

remembers the wine list. Are we putting

7:12

two and two together now? Cuz that

7:14

disconnect matters, Canada. It shows

7:17

exactly where the priorities of the

7:19

political class really lie right now in

7:22

this country. And listen, there was a

7:25

line I'm going to repeat for I'm going

7:27

to show it to you again in here that you

7:28

might have missed. But the most

7:30

revealing moment in that entire exchange

7:33

didn't actually come from the hardyhar

7:35

laughing or the wine story. It came from

7:39

one single sentence that slipped out

7:41

while Mark Carney was laughing with the

7:42

audience that everybody around this clip

7:45

has just some weariness about pointing

7:48

out clearly. While telling the story

7:50

about that seven course dinner during

7:51

the financial crisis, Carney said

7:54

something remarkable. He described the

7:56

Bear Sterns collapse, didn't he? Take a

7:58

look. 2 weeks into the job uh at

8:01

Governor of the Bank Canada. It's uh

8:03

February 2008. Uh, and I go there and

8:06

Bear Sterns is collapsing. Seemed like a

8:08

big deal at the time. In retrospect, it

8:10

was like that was nothing but it was a

8:11

big deal. Uh, seemed big at the time,

8:15

but was nothing.

8:18

Nothing really. Well, let's pause on

8:21

that line for a second, Mark, and think

8:23

about this for a second. Because if you

8:25

were one of the 15,000 employees at Bear

8:28

Sterns, I can promise you you didn't

8:30

feel like it was nothing. Those people

8:32

watched their entire company collapse

8:34

overnight. They lost their job. Their

8:37

careers were destroyed. Their retirement

8:39

savings wiped out. Bear Sterns was well

8:41

known that all employees invested in the

8:44

company. All of those savings wiped out,

8:47

gone, 15,000 people, entire families

8:50

forced to start over financially, sell

8:53

their homes, move into small homes. Bear

8:55

Stern's employees lost billions in stock

8:58

value and pensions had been built over

9:00

decades that were lost as well. For

9:02

them, that crisis wasn't a funny

9:04

anecdote told over a glass of expensive

9:07

European wine. It was the moment their

9:09

financial security vanished. So, no, it

9:12

wasn't nothing, Mark. And yet, we have

9:14

this prime minister of Canada describing

9:16

that moment as basically completely

9:19

insignificant. I don't think he meant it

9:21

maliciously. I don't know if he even

9:23

meant it angrily. I think it was just

9:25

casually because that's the life he

9:27

leads almost as a throwaway line in a

9:29

funny dinner story. And that right there

9:32

should tell you exactly everything that

9:35

you need to know about the difference

9:37

between how the financial elite like

9:39

Mark Carney experience crises like the

9:42

collapse of Bear Sterns and how ordinary

9:45

people experience them. Totally

9:47

different. Total disconnect for the

9:50

people sitting around those banker

9:51

tables in Basel. The collapse of Bear

9:54

Sterns was a policy problem to solve

9:57

before dessert. For the people working

9:59

inside Beer Sterns and the clients

10:01

affected by Bear Sterns, it was the day

10:04

their lives were turned completely

10:05

upside down that would take them nearly

10:07

a decade to recover from. That's the

10:10

difference between managing a crisis and

10:12

living through one. And the more

10:14

Canadians hear stories like this, the

10:16

more they're going to realize something

10:18

very uncomfortable about the prime

10:20

minister they voted for. The people

10:22

running the global financial system

10:24

often experience its failures very very

10:28

differently than the people who actually

10:30

suffer at the hand of those failures.

10:33

And this is a prime example with Bear

10:35

Sterns. Mark Carney calls it nothing,

10:37

the people affected by it would beg to

10:39

defer. And if this had happened during a

10:43

calm moment in global politics, it would

10:46

still be tonedeaf. But this timing makes

10:48

it even worse because right now the

10:51

world is watching a rapidly escalating

10:53

conflict in Iran and Mark Carney is

10:56

having a chuckle with the elite in

10:57

Australia. The Middle East is literally

11:00

on edge. Global energy markets are

11:03

nervous. Western governments are trying

11:06

to coordinate responses to a conflict

11:08

that could spo spiral into something

11:11

much larger as Iran again increases its

11:14

threats. This is not a moment for

11:17

light-hearted storytelling about wine

11:19

lists and banker dinners. It's a moment

11:22

that demands seriousness as a leader of

11:25

this country, as a leader in this world.

11:28

Leadership focus. Instead, we got

11:31

standup comedy in Australia, didn't we?

11:34

Instead, we got standup comedy about

11:36

central bankers arguing over penog

11:38

gregio. And again, the media is still

11:42

framing this like it is a charming

11:44

anecdote, a rare, light-hearted moment

11:46

from an otherwise serious prime

11:48

minister. But imagine for one second if

11:50

a conservative leader had acted like

11:52

that. Imagine if Pierre Polyv was

11:54

overseas laughing about luxury dinners

11:57

and very expensive wine lists, worrying

12:00

about who was going to have to pay and

12:01

be on the hook for that bill while

12:03

Canadians were struggling. The media

12:06

would be calling it completely out of

12:07

touch, completely unhinged. They would

12:10

say it proves he doesn't understand

12:12

ordinary people across this country. But

12:14

when Mark Carney does it, it's

12:16

lightigh-hearted moments. It's laughing

12:18

around. It's just being part of the

12:20

guys. Suddenly, it's personality we

12:23

don't get to see very often. Suddenly,

12:25

it's relatability to the rest of us

12:27

because he knows how to laugh. Suddenly,

12:29

it's refreshing. That double standard is

12:32

impossible to ignore in this country

12:34

anymore and we need to call it out every

12:37

single damn time we see it. This moment

12:39

exposes something deeper about Canada

12:41

govern Canada's governing class. They

12:44

live in a completely different reality

12:47

than you do. If you are a liberal,

12:49

conservative, NDP Green, I don't care

12:51

who's watching this, you live in a

12:52

different world than Mark Carney. Think

12:54

about the room Mark Carney was speaking

12:56

to. The Loey Institute in Sydney,

12:59

Australia. Do you know who they are?

13:01

They're a global policy think tank.

13:03

They're a giant room of diplomats,

13:06

policy elites, and academics. Not one

13:09

person like the rest of us across this

13:12

country. It's financial insiders. These

13:14

are the people who attend Davos. And

13:18

again, when you saw the standing ovation

13:20

in Davos, those were his people. Wake

13:23

up. These are the people who attend

13:26

World Economic Forum meetings. These are

13:29

the people who fly between global

13:30

conferences discussing the future of

13:33

this world. And when they talk about

13:35

economic crises like things like the

13:38

collapse of Bear Sterns, they talk about

13:40

them over seven course dinners with the

13:43

best wine in Europe. Mark Carney just

13:45

admitted that in that clip. That's their

13:48

world. It's not yours. It's certainly

13:50

not our world here in Canada, is it?

13:53

We're not seeing anything of the sort.

13:54

We're not seeing the average Canadian

13:56

family order a thousand dollar of

13:58

European wine. The average Canadian is

14:00

facing mortgage renewals this year. The

14:02

average Canadian is facing job losses

14:04

this year. They're debating whether they

14:06

can keep their home or not this year.

14:09

The average family standing in line at a

14:11

food bank isn't reminiscing about luxury

14:13

dinners in Switzerland, are they?

14:15

They're wondering how to feed their

14:17

children. And when the prime minister

14:19

uses your taxpayer money to fly across

14:22

the world and laugh about the elite

14:24

lifestyle, it reminds people exactly how

14:28

far removed this political class has

14:30

become from everyday reality. That's the

14:33

bottom line. $300,000 of your taxpayer

14:36

money to fly him there to go and laugh

14:38

in that room. And where was Matt Geroo,

14:41

by the way, who's attended this entire

14:42

trip? Probably in the audience. So why

14:45

is this media making light out of all of

14:47

this? Why are they framing it as

14:49

harmless? Because Mark Carney represents

14:51

the same world view as the institutions

14:54

that are covering him. The same global

14:57

institutions, the same policy networks,

15:01

the same academic circles. He's one of

15:04

them. And he's not going to ever be one

15:08

of you. That's why stories like this are

15:11

softened. The tone becomes lighthearted

15:15

because they are part of his world, not

15:18

part of your world. The language becomes

15:21

relaxed. He's calm. It's a new

15:23

light-hearted moment from our prime

15:25

minister.

15:27

The focus becomes how charming the

15:29

moment was. Are you kidding me? Instead

15:32

of asking the obvious question that most

15:34

of us are asking, why is Canada's prime

15:36

minister joking about luxury dinners

15:38

while the country faces an affordability

15:41

crisis? Why was he allowed to fly a

15:43

$300,000 perflight plane over there to

15:46

do this? It's the same media ecosystem

15:48

that spent years telling Canada their

15:50

declining living standards were either

15:52

imaginary or necessary for climate

15:55

policy to be achieved. Now, that same

15:58

ecosystem wants you to believe this

15:59

moment was no big deal. on the world

16:01

stage. It's a light-hearted, laughing

16:03

prime minister. But Canadians, well,

16:06

we're starting to see through all of

16:07

that, aren't we? And in the end, this

16:09

story about wine isn't really about

16:13

wine. It's about the distance between

16:15

Canada's political elite and the people

16:18

that they govern. This was a disgusting

16:21

display of what we all knew was already

16:23

happening, but now it's on tape. For the

16:25

people in that room in Sydney, the story

16:28

was funny. For Canadians struggling to

16:30

pay their bills, it felt like a giant

16:33

slap in the face with the back of Mark

16:35

Carney's hand. And moments like this

16:37

matter because they reveal something

16:40

much, much deeper. They reveal that the

16:42

culture of the ruling class is way off

16:45

of the culture of everyone else. A

16:48

culture where global elites gather for

16:50

luxury dinners while debating economic

16:52

policy, shrugging off collapses like

16:55

Bear Sterns, and getting frustrated by

16:57

the giant wine list. A culture where the

16:59

consequences of those policies are felt

17:01

by ordinary people thousands and

17:04

thousands of miles away back at home.

17:06

And a culture where the media will

17:08

always rush to protect its own. And one

17:10

of its own is Mark Carney. Canada

17:13

deserves leaders who understand the

17:15

country that they actually govern and

17:18

the people that they have to lead.

17:21

Leaders who recognize the struggles

17:23

people are facing on an everyday basis.

17:26

leaders who know that when families are

17:28

struggling to afford their groceries,

17:30

maybe it's not the time to go to

17:32

Australia and sit there and joke about

17:35

seven course dinners and the luxury

17:37

thousand wine list. But what we saw in

17:40

Sydney wasn't just a joke. It was a

17:42

glimpse into the mindset of the global

17:45

elite. And the more Canadians see

17:47

moments like that garbage that we just

17:49

saw at the top of this show, the more

17:52

they're going to start asking a very

17:54

simple question. And you absolutely

17:57

should be asking it. Whose country is

17:59

this really being run for?

18:03

That's how you tap into the truth. Talk

18:05

about it in the comments. Let's go.

18:07

Let's have the conversation. You know

18:09

what I'm talking about. Let's do it.

18:11

Thanks for watching. We'll see you this

18:13

afternoon at 2 o'clock. Have a great day

18:15

everybody.

UNLOCK MORE

Sign up free to access premium features

INTERACTIVE VIEWER

Watch the video with synced subtitles, adjustable overlay, and full playback control.

SIGN UP FREE TO UNLOCK

AI SUMMARY

Get an instant AI-generated summary of the video content, key points, and takeaways.

SIGN UP FREE TO UNLOCK

TRANSLATE

Translate the transcript to 100+ languages with one click. Download in any format.

SIGN UP FREE TO UNLOCK

MIND MAP

Visualize the transcript as an interactive mind map. Understand structure at a glance.

SIGN UP FREE TO UNLOCK

CHAT WITH TRANSCRIPT

Ask questions about the video content. Get answers powered by AI directly from the transcript.

SIGN UP FREE TO UNLOCK

GET MORE FROM YOUR TRANSCRIPTS

Sign up for free and unlock interactive viewer, AI summaries, translations, mind maps, and more. No credit card required.