TRANSCRIPTEnglish

Video W5VjfbGaBo0

1h 2m 30s8,454 words1,457 segmentsEnglish

FULL TRANSCRIPT

0:00

In the pre-dawn darkness of June 4th,

0:02

1942,

0:04

many young Japanese pilots sit in their

0:06

cockpits aboard four aircraft carriers,

0:09

breathing deeply of the Pacific morning

0:11

air. Others are being briefed in ready

0:13

rooms, studying their target maps one

0:16

final time. Still others, mechanics and

0:19

deck crews, are making lastminute

0:21

adjustments to aircraft that will soon

0:23

launch into history. Unknown to them,

0:26

240 mi to the northeast, three American

0:29

carriers are already turning into the

0:31

wind, preparing to launch their own

0:33

strikes. In just a few hours, what was

0:36

meant to be Japan's decisive victory,

0:39

the elimination of American carrier

0:41

power in the Pacific will instead become

0:43

the Empire's most catastrophic defeat.

0:47

Four Japanese carriers that had

0:49

triumphed at Pearl Harbor will slip

0:51

beneath the waves, taking with them not

0:53

just steel and fuel, but the dreams of

0:56

Japanese expansion and over 3,000

0:58

irreplaceable airmen and sailors. This

1:01

had been the culmination of six months

1:03

of victories. And now, for the first

1:05

time, this pivotal battle will be viewed

1:08

through the eyes of those who lost it.

1:10

The Japanese admirals who planned it,

1:13

the pilots who flew it, and the sailors

1:15

who died in it. This is the Battle of

1:18

Midway. It is the spring of 1942,

1:22

2 months before the disaster at Midway.

1:25

Currently in Tokyo, Admiral Isuroku

1:27

Yamamoto, commanderin-chief of the

1:30

combined fleet, is locked in heated

1:32

arguments with the naval general staff.

1:34

Things are not going as smoothly as the

1:36

public believes. The previous December's

1:39

attack on Pearl Harbor, while tactically

1:41

brilliant, had failed to destroy even a

1:44

single American aircraft carrier. This

1:46

reality haunts Yamamoto's every waking

1:49

moment. The USS Enterprise and USS

1:53

Lexington had been at sea during the

1:55

attack. And now, 6 months later, these

1:58

carriers continue to strike at Japanese

2:00

forces across the Pacific. Worse still,

2:03

on April 18th, American B-25 bombers

2:07

launched from the carrier USS Hornet had

2:10

appeared in the skies over Tokyo itself.

2:13

The do little raid, an unthinkable

2:15

humiliation for the Japanese military

2:17

that had sworn to protect the emperor

2:19

from all harm. This raid, while causing

2:22

minimal physical damage, had created a

2:25

psychological earthquake within Japanese

2:27

leadership. The vulnerability of the

2:30

homeland had been exposed, and someone

2:32

had to take responsibility.

2:35

Vice Admiral Tichi Nagumo, who had led

2:37

the Pearl Harbor attack, was

2:39

particularly shaken. He had been

2:41

criticized for not launching a third

2:43

wave at Pearl Harbor, for not finding

2:45

the American carriers, and now Tokyo

2:48

itself had been bombed. The pressure for

2:51

a decisive action was immense, but the

2:54

Japanese high command was, as always,

2:56

deeply divided. In the corridors of

2:59

power, two competing strategies emerged.

3:02

The naval general staff, conservative

3:05

and cautious, advocated for a southern

3:07

strategy, continuing to consolidate

3:10

gains in the Solomon Islands and New

3:12

Guinea, cutting the supply lines between

3:14

America and Australia. But Yamamoto had

3:17

a different vision, one born of both

3:20

opportunity and desperation.

3:22

He knew something that few others in

3:24

Japan truly understood. Time was not on

3:27

their side. During his years in America,

3:31

studying at Harvard and serving as a

3:33

naval attache, Yamamoto had witnessed

3:36

American industrial might firsthand. He

3:38

had seen the steel mills of Pittsburgh,

3:41

the shipyards of Newport News, the

3:43

endless farmlands that could feed

3:45

millions of workers. Once America's war

3:48

machine reached full production, Japan

3:50

would be overwhelmed by sheer material

3:53

superiority.

3:54

As Yamamoto would tell Prime Minister

3:56

Fumimaru Kono in a documented

3:59

conversation from 1940,

4:01

"If we are ordered to do it, then I can

4:04

guarantee to put up a tough fight for

4:05

the first 6 months, but I have

4:07

absolutely no confidence as to what

4:09

would happen if it went on for 2 or 3

4:11

years." This prediction would prove

4:14

prophetically accurate. In another

4:16

verified statement from September 1941,

4:20

he had warned, "For a while we'll have

4:22

everything our own way, stretching out

4:24

in every direction like an octopus

4:27

spreading its tentacles, but it'll last

4:30

for a year and a half at the most."

4:33

The solution, Yamamoto argued, was

4:35

Operation MI, the invasion of Midway at

4:40

this tiny pair of islands, just six

4:42

square miles of coral and sand, held

4:45

strategic importance far beyond its

4:47

size. Located 1,100 mi northwest of

4:51

Pearl Harbor, Midway served as America's

4:54

westernmost outpost, a crucial refueling

4:57

station for submarines and aircraft

4:59

patrolling the central Pacific. But more

5:01

importantly for Yamamoto, Midway would

5:04

serve as bait. Irresistible bait that

5:07

would draw out the American carriers

5:08

from Pearl Harbor. When they came to

5:11

defend the atole, the superior Japanese

5:13

fleet would destroy them in a decisive

5:16

battle. The Kai Kessan that Japanese

5:18

naval doctrine had always envisioned.

5:21

The plan was complex, perhaps too

5:24

complex. It involved multiple forces

5:27

operating across thousands of miles of

5:29

ocean. an invasion fleet to capture

5:31

Midway, a carrier strike force to

5:34

destroy American air power, a main body

5:36

with battleships, including Yamamoto's

5:39

flagship, the mighty Yamato, and even a

5:41

diversionary attack on the Aleutian

5:43

Islands to confuse the Americans. Some

5:46

200 ships in total, the largest fleet

5:49

Japan had ever assembled. The operation

5:52

order alone ran to 700 pages,

5:54

distributed only days before sailing,

5:57

giving subordinate commanders barely any

5:59

time to study it. Opposition to the plan

6:02

was significant, but ultimately futile.

6:06

Rear Admiral Mat Ugaki, Yamamoto's chief

6:10

of staff, conducted war games in early

6:12

May that showed disturbing results. In

6:16

the tabletop exercises, the American

6:18

carriers appeared earlier than expected

6:20

and inflicted serious damage on the

6:23

Japanese fleet. But these results were

6:25

literally overruled. The umpires

6:28

arbitrarily reduced American hits and

6:30

refloated Japanese ships that had been

6:32

sunk in the exercise.

6:35

When Lieutenant Commander Minoru Jender,

6:38

the brilliant tactical planner who had

6:40

designed the Pearl Harbor attack,

6:42

expressed concerns about the operation's

6:44

complexity and the vulnerability of the

6:46

carriers, he was dismissed. The victory

6:49

disease, that fatal overconfidence born

6:52

from 6 months of easy conquests, had

6:54

infected even the most brilliant minds

6:56

in the Imperial Navy. The Japanese

6:59

believed they had sunk two American

7:01

carriers at Coral Sea in May. They had

7:04

actually sunk only one, the USS

7:06

Lexington. They assumed the USS Yorktown

7:10

was so badly damaged she would be out of

7:12

action for months.

7:14

Japanese intelligence had failed to

7:16

detect the frantic repair efforts at

7:18

Pearl Harbor, where 1,400 workers

7:21

labored around the clock to patch up

7:23

Yorktown in just 3 days, a feat Japanese

7:26

shipyards could never have accomplished.

7:29

They calculated the Americans could have

7:31

at most two operational carriers to

7:33

oppose them. Meanwhile, the man chosen

7:36

to lead the carrier strike force, Vice

7:39

Admiral Chuichi Nagamo, harbored his own

7:42

deep doubts. Nagamo was not a carrier

7:45

admiral by training or temperament. A

7:47

torpedo specialist who had been

7:49

appointed to command the first airfleet

7:51

more by seniority than expertise. He had

7:54

never been comfortable with naval

7:55

aviation. At Pearl Harbor, his caution

7:59

had prevented a third strike that might

8:01

have destroyed the American fuel depots

8:03

and repair facilities. Now he was being

8:06

asked to lead an even more complex

8:07

operation with an increasingly worn out

8:10

force. His carriers had been at sea

8:12

almost continuously since Pearl Harbor,

8:15

striking Darwin, Salon, and supporting

8:18

operations from the Indian Ocean to the

8:20

Coral Sea. His air crews were exhausted,

8:24

and the ships needed maintenance. Most

8:26

troublingly, the recent battle of the

8:29

Coral Sea in May had cost Japan dearly.

8:33

While tactically a Japanese victory with

8:35

the sinking of the Lexington,

8:36

strategically it was a setback. The

8:39

carrier Shokaku had been badly damaged

8:41

and would need months of repairs. Her

8:44

sister ship Zuikaku had lost so many

8:47

aircraft and pilots that she could not

8:49

participate in the midway operation. Two

8:52

of Japan's best carriers would be absent

8:54

from the decisive battle.

8:56

As Nagamo confided to his chief of

8:58

staff, Captain Ryunosuk Kusaka, "We are

9:02

being asked to do too much with too

9:04

little. The Americans have had time to

9:06

prepare. Our pilots are tired, and we

9:09

don't even know where their carriers

9:10

are. Yamamotoan is gambling with the

9:13

fate of the empire." But perhaps the

9:16

most fatal flaw in the Japanese plan was

9:18

one of intelligence and mindset. Unknown

9:21

to the Japanese, the Americans had

9:24

broken the Japanese Navy's JN25B

9:27

code.

9:29

Commander Joseph Rashfort, station hypo

9:31

at Pearl Harbor, had been reading

9:33

Japanese messages since early 1942.

9:37

The Americans knew about Operation MI,

9:40

knew the target was Midway, confirmed

9:42

through the famous AF ruse, where Midway

9:45

broadcast false reports of water

9:47

shortage via secure cable, then

9:50

intercepted Japanese messages that AF

9:53

was short on water and knew the

9:56

approximate date of the attack.

9:58

Admiral Chester Nimitz had complete

10:00

Japanese order of battle and could

10:02

position his forces accordingly. The

10:05

Japanese submarine cordon meant to

10:07

detect American ships leaving Pearl

10:09

Harbor would arrive on station too late.

10:11

The American carriers had already passed

10:14

through. The planned reconnaissance by

10:16

flying boats of Pearl Harbor, Operation

10:19

K was cancelled when submarine Natapshad

10:22

123 found American warships USS Thornton

10:26

and USS Pelba occupying French frigot

10:29

Scholes, the intended refueling point.

10:33

This had worked in March when two

10:35

Kawanishi H8K flying boats had refueled

10:38

there from submarines to bomb Aahu, but

10:41

Nimmits had learned from that raid. One

10:44

by one, the eyes that might have warned

10:46

of the American ambush were being

10:47

blinded.

10:49

Radio intelligence did indicate

10:51

increased American submarine activity

10:53

and message traffic around Midway. The

10:56

ease with which the Americans had found

10:58

Japanese forces at Coral Sea suggested

11:01

their codes might be compromised. But

11:03

these warnings were dismissed. As one

11:06

staff officer put it, "The Americans are

11:08

too stupid to break our codes and too

11:10

cowardly to fight unless they have

11:12

overwhelming superiority.

11:15

They will come to Midway only after we

11:17

have taken it, and then we will destroy

11:19

them." On May 27th, the anniversary of

11:23

Admiral Togo's great victory over the

11:25

Russians at Tsushima, Nagumo's carrier

11:28

strike force, the Kido Bhutai, sailed

11:31

from the inland sea. Four carriers

11:34

departed. Akagi, Red Castle, Yamamoto's

11:37

former command, and Nagumo's flagship.

11:40

Kaga, Increased Joy, the converted

11:43

battleship. Hiu, flying dragon, and

11:46

Soryu, green dragon. Between them they

11:49

carried 248 aircraft including 2110

11:53

being fed to Midway with 225 operational

11:57

for combat and the most experienced

11:59

naval aviators in the world. These were

12:02

the ships and men who had devastated

12:04

Pearl Harbor who had rampaged from

12:06

Hawaii to Salon. Surely nothing could

12:09

stop them.

12:11

Commander Minoru Jender, still

12:13

recuperating from his emergency

12:14

appendecttomy, but serving as Nagumo's

12:17

air operations officer despite his

12:19

illness, made a final entry in his diary

12:22

before departure.

12:24

We sail with heavy hearts. This

12:26

operation has been rushed. Our

12:28

intelligence is poor, and the plan is

12:30

too complex. But we are samurai. We will

12:33

do our duty even if it leads to death.

12:36

May the gods protect Japan, for I fear

12:39

we sail toward catastrophe.

12:41

The fatal flaw of overconfidence was

12:44

perhaps best exemplified by the

12:46

treatment of Commander Mitsuo Fuida, who

12:48

had led the Pearl Harbor attack. In late

12:51

May, Fuida underwent an emergency

12:54

appendecttomy aboard a Kagi. The surgery

12:57

left him too weak to fly, depriving the

13:00

Japanese of their most experienced

13:01

strike leader at the most critical

13:03

moment. According to later testimony

13:06

from other officers, Fuida watched the

13:08

preparations from his sick bed with

13:10

growing unease, sensing that everything

13:13

about this operation felt wrong. The

13:16

timing, the plan, the very air itself

13:18

seemed heavy with impending doom.

13:21

However, historians note that Fuida's

13:24

postwar accounts must be treated with

13:26

caution, as modern scholarship has

13:28

challenged many of his claims. In the

13:31

pre-dawn darkness of June 3rd, 600 m to

13:34

the north, the Alleutian Islands

13:36

operation begins.

13:39

Rear Admiral Kakuji Kakutoa's second

13:41

carrier strike force with the light

13:43

carriers Ryujo and Juno launches strikes

13:46

against Dutch Harbor in Alaska. This is

13:50

meant to be the Great Diversion, pulling

13:52

American forces north while Nagumo

13:54

attacks Midway. But unknown to the

13:57

Japanese, the Americans have not taken

13:59

the bait.

14:01

Admiral Chester Nimmitz, fully informed

14:03

by his codereakers of the real target,

14:06

has kept his carriers at midway. The

14:09

elaborate deception has deceived no one

14:11

but the Japanese themselves.

14:14

Meanwhile, Nagumo's carriers steam

14:16

through fog toward their launch point,

14:18

maintaining strict radio silence that

14:21

will prevent any coordination between

14:23

the widely separated forces. In the

14:25

ready rooms, pilots receive their final

14:28

briefings. Lieutenant Joyi Tomminaga,

14:31

who will lead the first strike, studies

14:33

the reconnaissance photos of Midway one

14:36

last time. The images are weeks old, but

14:39

they show the airfield, the fuel tanks,

14:41

the defensive positions. What they don't

14:43

show is the recent reinforcement of the

14:46

island, the additional fighters,

14:48

bombers, and most crucially, the radar

14:50

station that will detect the Japanese

14:52

strike while it's still 93 mi away.

14:56

That evening, American PBY Catalina

14:58

flying boats spot portions of the

15:00

Japanese invasion fleet 700 m west of

15:03

Midway. This first contact electrifies

15:06

the American command. Navy pilot Enen

15:09

Jack Reed flying a PBY reports at 0925.

15:15

Cited main body bearing 262 distance

15:18

700. But Nagumo's carriers remain

15:21

undetected, hidden by weather and

15:24

distance. On the bridge of Akagi, the

15:26

tension is palpable. Chief of Staff

15:29

Kusaka approaches Nagumo.

15:32

Sir, if the Americans have spotted the

15:34

invasion force, they may be more alert

15:36

than we expected. Nagumo dismisses the

15:39

concern.

15:41

The invasion force is supposed to be

15:43

seen. It will draw them out. Tomorrow,

15:46

we will destroy their air power on

15:47

Midway. And when their carriers arrive

15:50

to counterattack, we will be waiting.

15:53

But even as Nagumo speaks these

15:55

confident words, 300 m to the northeast,

15:58

Admiral Raymond Spruent aboard USS

16:01

Enterprise is plotting the Japanese

16:03

carrier forc's probable position. The

16:06

American carriers are exactly where they

16:08

shouldn't be according to Japanese

16:09

calculations. Already at sea, already in

16:13

position, already preparing to strike.

16:16

Task Force 16 under Spruent with

16:18

Enterprise and Hornet and Task Force 17

16:21

under Admiral Frank Jack Fletcher with

16:23

the hastily repaired Yorktown have

16:26

reached Point Luck their designated

16:28

rendevous northeast of Midway undetected

16:31

by any Japanese reconnaissance.

16:34

The weather is clear, the seas calm,

16:36

perfect flying conditions with

16:38

visibility extending for miles. At

16:41

precisely 0430, Akagi and Kaga begin

16:45

launching the first wave against Midway.

16:48

The launch proceeds smoothly. 36 ID 3A

16:52

Val dive bombers, 36 Nakajima, B5N Kate

16:57

level bombers and 36 Mitsubishi A6M0

17:01

fighters. Lieutenant Tomminaga leads

17:04

them into the lightning sky, circling

17:07

once over the fleet before heading

17:08

southeast toward Midway, 240 mi distant.

17:13

As the 108 aircraft form up and depart,

17:16

Nagumo makes his first fateful decision

17:19

of the day. Despite doctrine calling for

17:22

a full deckload strike to maximize

17:24

impact, he holds back 108 aircraft.

17:27

Kates armed with type 91 torpedoes and

17:30

800 kg armor-piercing bombs in case

17:33

American ships appear. It seems prudent,

17:36

but it will prove catastrophic.

17:39

Below decks in the hanger of a kagi,

17:41

Commander Mitsuo Fuida watches the

17:44

launch from his sick bed, still

17:45

recovering from his appendecttomy. The

17:48

absence of his experience and tactical

17:50

genius will be keenly felt in the hours

17:52

to come. According to witness accounts

17:55

from other officers, Fuchida expressed

17:58

deep concern about the operation, though

18:00

his specific words remain unverified in

18:03

contemporary documents.

18:05

At 0500, Nagumo launches his search

18:08

planes, just seven aircraft to cover a

18:11

vast expanse of ocean. By contrast, the

18:14

Americans have over 30 PBYs searching

18:17

for the Japanese fleet. Most critically,

18:20

the search plane from the heavy cruiser

18:22

tone, designated as number four scout

18:25

and assigned to search the sector where

18:27

the American carriers actually are

18:30

launches 30 minutes late. Various

18:33

sources attribute this to catapult

18:35

problems, though some suggest engine

18:37

trouble or bureaucratic delays. This

18:40

single mechanical failure will cascade

18:42

into catastrophe.

18:44

Ironically, recent scholarship suggests

18:46

that had the plane launched on time, its

18:49

search pattern might have missed the

18:50

American task forces entirely. At 0534,

18:55

PBY pilot Lieutenant Howard AD spots the

18:58

Japanese carriers and transmits the

19:00

electrifying message, "Enemy carriers."

19:04

He follows with more detail at 0552.

19:08

Two carriers and battleships bearing

19:10

320°,

19:12

distance 180 mi, course 135, speed 25.

19:18

On Enterprise, Spruent makes a command

19:21

decision that will determine the

19:23

battle's outcome. Despite the extreme

19:25

range, nearly 200 m, he orders an

19:29

immediate strike. His aircraft will have

19:31

barely enough fuel to return, but he

19:34

wants to catch the Japanese when they're

19:36

most vulnerable. recovering their midway

19:38

strike.

19:40

Meanwhile, at 0553,

19:42

radar on midway picks up the incoming

19:45

Japanese strike 93 miles out. Air raid

19:48

sirens whale across the tiny atole.

19:52

Every available aircraft is scrambled.

19:54

Bombers to attack the Japanese fleet,

19:57

fighters to defend. Marine fighters

20:00

launch into the air. 20 obsolete

20:02

Brewster F 2 A Buffaloos and seven

20:05

Grumman F 4F Wildcats. They are

20:09

outnumbered four to one by the escorting

20:11

zeros. The interception occurs at 0616.

20:16

Marine Major Floyd Parks leading the

20:18

defenders makes his final radio

20:20

transmission. Hawks at Angels 14

20:23

supported by fighters. The massacre is

20:26

swift and brutal. The Zeros with their

20:29

superior maneuverability and experienced

20:31

pilots tear through the marine

20:33

formation. Within minutes, 13 Marine

20:37

fighters are shot down, four severely

20:39

damaged. Major Parks is among the dead.

20:43

The Zeros lose just three planes. At

20:46

0630,

20:47

Tomminaga's strike force arrives over

20:49

Midway. The dive bombers and level

20:52

bombers execute their attacks with

20:54

precision, setting fuel tanks ablaze,

20:57

destroying buildings, cratering the

20:59

runway. But as Tomaga circles to assess

21:02

damage, he sees something troubling.

21:05

American aircraft are still taking off

21:07

from the supposedly destroyed airfield.

21:09

The runway, while damaged, is still

21:11

operational.

21:13

Most importantly, none of the American

21:15

aircraft were caught on the ground. They

21:17

had all been launched before the strike

21:19

arrived. At 0700, Tomminaga radios

21:24

Nagumo. There is need for a second

21:26

attack wave.

21:28

This message reaches Nagumo at 0700 just

21:32

as the first American strikes from

21:34

Midway begin arriving. First come six

21:37

TBF Avengers and four B-26 Marauders

21:40

carrying torpedoes. The Zeros assigned

21:43

to combat air patrol swarm them. Five

21:46

Avengers are shot down, two B26

21:49

destroyed. But one B-26, nicknamed Suzie

21:53

Q and piloted by Lieutenant James

21:56

Murray, makes a desperate run directly

21:58

at a Kagi after dropping his torpedo.

22:01

According to multiple Japanese

22:03

witnesses, including bridge personnel,

22:06

the bomber roared down the length of

22:08

Aagi's flight deck, its gunners strafing

22:11

and killing two sailors. The plane

22:14

pulled up at the last second, barely

22:16

clearing the bridge where Nagumo and his

22:18

staff ducked for cover. Muri's aircraft

22:21

sustained over 500 bullet holes and lost

22:24

hydraulic fluid, but somehow made it

22:26

back to Midway. A second B26, piloted by

22:30

Lieutenant Herbert Mays and heavily

22:32

damaged, actually crashed into the ocean

22:34

near a Kagi's bridge, possibly

22:37

attempting a deliberate ramming attack.

22:39

This near miss has a profound

22:41

psychological effect. As Captain Kusaka

22:44

would later testify, the admiral was

22:47

visibly shaken. To have an enemy plane

22:50

nearly crash into the bridge, it was as

22:52

if the war god had given us a warning.

22:56

More American attacks follow in rapid

22:58

succession. 16 Marine dive bombers led

23:02

by Major Loftton Henderson, who would be

23:04

killed leading his squadron. 15B7

23:07

bombing from high altitude, 11 marine

23:10

vindicators.

23:11

All are repulsed with heavy losses,

23:14

scoring no hits, but they keep the

23:16

Japanese carriers dodging and weaving,

23:18

unable to conduct flight operations

23:20

efficiently.

23:22

At 0715,

23:24

Nagumo faces a critical decision. His

23:27

reserve aircraft are armed with

23:28

armor-piercing bombs and torpedoes for

23:30

ship attack. But Tomminaga needs support

23:33

at midway, and no enemy carriers have

23:35

been spotted. After heated discussion

23:38

with his staff, Nagumo issues the order

23:41

that seals his fate. Remove torpedoes,

23:44

load land attack bombs. This violates

23:47

Yamamoto's explicit orders to maintain

23:49

readiness for anti-ship operations. Down

23:53

in the hangar decks of all four

23:54

carriers, chaos erupts. Ordinance crews

23:58

begin the laborious process of removing

24:00

type 91 torpedoes and 800 kg

24:03

armor-piercing bombs, replacing them

24:05

with smaller land attack munitions.

24:08

Against regulations and safety

24:10

protocols, the removed torpedoes are

24:12

stacked in the hanger spaces rather than

24:15

being returned to the magazines far

24:17

below. There isn't time. Bombs are piled

24:20

near the aircraft. Fuel hoses snake

24:23

everywhere as planes are refueled. As

24:26

one mechanic, Airman my would later

24:29

testify if he had survived. The hangar

24:32

deck looked like a bomb factory. One

24:34

spark and we would all be dead. At 0728,

24:39

everything changes. The tone's delayed

24:42

scout plane number four finally reports.

24:45

Sight what appears to be 10 enemy

24:47

surface ships bearing 010 degrees.

24:51

Distance 240 mi from midway. Course 150°

24:56

speed over 20 knots. Nagumo immediately

24:59

signals ascertain ship types. The

25:03

response doesn't come for 12 agonizing

25:05

minutes. Meanwhile, the riming

25:08

continues, the hanger decks becoming

25:10

increasingly cluttered with ordinance.

25:12

At 0745,

25:14

another American strike arrives. 16

25:17

Marine dive bombers from VMSB 241 led by

25:21

Major Henderson. The Zeros savage them,

25:24

shooting down eight, but the attacks

25:26

keep coming, forcing violent evasive

25:29

maneuvers that prevent flight

25:30

operations.

25:32

Nagumo is trapped in an impossible

25:34

position. His fighters are running low

25:36

on fuel and ammunition from fighting off

25:38

continuous attacks. Tomaga's strike

25:41

force will return soon, also low on

25:44

fuel. His decks are spotted with

25:46

aircraft being rearmed. And somewhere

25:48

out there are American surface ships,

25:50

possibly carriers. At 0809, tone number

25:55

four scout finally clarifies.

25:57

Enemy ships are five cruisers and five

26:00

destroyers. Nagumo breathes a sigh of

26:02

relief, no carriers, and continues

26:05

rearming for a second midway strike. But

26:08

at 0820, another message shatters his

26:11

composure.

26:13

The enemy is accompanied by what appears

26:15

to be a carrier.

26:17

Rear Admiral Tamman Yamaguchi,

26:19

commanding the second carrier division

26:21

from Hiru, immediately signals Nagumo at

26:24

0830.

26:26

Consider it advisable to launch attack

26:28

force immediately.

26:30

Yamaguchi, aggressive and decisive, sees

26:33

the danger clearly. Every minute of

26:36

delay increases vulnerability, but

26:38

Nagumo hesitates. His aircraft are in

26:42

chaos. Some armed with bombs, some with

26:44

torpedoes, many not armed at all. His

26:48

fighters need to land and refuel.

26:51

Tomminaga's returning strike is

26:53

approaching. To launch now would mean a

26:56

partial uncoordinated attack with no

26:58

fighter escort, violating every

27:00

principle of Japanese carrier doctrine.

27:03

Commander Minorugu Jender, despite his

27:06

illness from the appendecttomy, is

27:08

consulted. According to staff officer

27:10

testimonies, he argued for an immediate

27:13

launch. Speed is everything now. Launch

27:17

what we have. But Captain Kusaka

27:19

council's caution. If we attack peace

27:22

meal, we'll suffer heavy losses for

27:24

little gain. Better to recover our

27:27

aircraft, properly arm them, and launch

27:29

a fully constituted strike according to

27:32

doctrine.

27:33

Nagumo, always cautious, always by the

27:36

book, sides with Kusaka. We will recover

27:39

Tom Monoga's force, rearm and refuel

27:42

properly, and then strike with full

27:44

strength. He signals all carriers.

27:47

After completing recovery of aircraft,

27:49

we shall proceed north to engage the

27:51

enemy. This decision, logical, prudent,

27:55

and completely wrong, seals the fate of

27:57

the Kido Bhutai. As Tommanaga's planes

28:01

land starting at 0837 and are struck

28:04

below to be refueled and rearmed, the

28:07

hanger decks become death traps. Fuel

28:10

lines are everywhere. Bombs and

28:12

torpedoes are scattered about. The

28:14

constant cycling of elevators brings

28:16

planes up and down. Safety protocols are

28:20

completely abandoned in the rush to

28:22

prepare for launch. No one notices the

28:24

first American torpedo planes appearing

28:26

on the horizon until it's too late. At

28:29

0920, the first American carrier planes

28:32

arrive. 15 TBD Devastator torpedo

28:36

bombers from Hornets torpedo squadron 8

28:39

VT8 led by Lieutenant Commander John

28:42

Waldron. Without fighter escort, flying

28:44

obsolete aircraft at just 100 knots,

28:47

barely above the waves, they bore in

28:49

against the entire Japanese fleet. The

28:52

zeros on combat air patrol finally with

28:55

worthy targets after hours of fighting

28:57

off land-based attacks descend like

29:00

hawks on pigeons. The massacre is total.

29:03

One by one, the slow, vulnerable torpedo

29:06

bombers are shot down. All 15 are

29:09

destroyed. Of 30 air crew, only one

29:12

survives. Enen George Gay, who will

29:15

float in the water, hiding under his

29:17

seat cushion, watching the rest of the

29:19

battle unfold. Not a single torpedo

29:22

hits, but Waldron's sacrifice is not in

29:25

vain. The Zeros are all drawn down to

29:28

sea level, focused on the torpedo

29:30

planes. At 0954,

29:33

14 Devastators from Enterprises VT6

29:36

arrive, led by Lieutenant Commander

29:39

Eugene Lindsay. Again, the Zeros swarm

29:42

down. 10 are shot down, four escape, no

29:46

hits.

29:48

At 1012 devastators from Yorktown's VT3

29:51

attack led by Lieutenant Commander Lance

29:54

Massie, 10 more shot down. Still no

29:57

torpedo hits. Of 41 torpedo bombers that

30:00

attack, only six survive. It seems like

30:03

another slaughter for nothing. On the

30:06

bridge of Aagi, there is relief, even

30:08

celebration. The American attacks have

30:11

been repulsed with terrible losses.

30:13

Nagumo orders the strike force to

30:15

prepare for launch at 10:30. Victory

30:18

seems within grasp, but high above,

30:21

unnoticed with every zero at sea level,

30:24

two groups of SBD dauntless dive bombers

30:27

arrive simultaneously.

30:29

Lieutenant Commander Wade McCcluskey,

30:31

leading 33 dive bombers from Enterprise,

30:34

had searched beyond his calculated

30:36

interception point, gambling his fuel to

30:39

find the Japanese.

30:41

He had spotted the destroyer Arashi

30:43

speeding north. It had been depth

30:45

charging the submarine USS Nautilus and

30:48

followed its course directly to the Kido

30:51

Bhutai. Meanwhile, Lieutenant Commander

30:54

Max Leslie's 17 dive bombers from

30:56

Yorktown arrived from a different

30:58

direction at the same moment. At 10:20,

31:02

lookouts on a kagi scream, "Hell

31:04

divers!" But it's too late. With the

31:08

zeros at sea level, with the decks

31:10

packed with fueled and armed aircraft,

31:12

with bombs and torpedoes scattered

31:14

throughout the hanger spaces, the

31:16

Japanese carriers are perfectly

31:18

vulnerable. At 10:22, McCcluskey pushes

31:22

over into his dive from 14,500 ft.

31:26

Behind him, his squadrons roll into

31:28

their attack dives. The rising sun

31:31

insignia on the carrier decks below grow

31:33

larger, becoming perfect targets in the

31:36

crystalline Pacific morning.

31:39

Lieutenant Commander McCcluskey leads

31:41

his bombers against Kaga, while

31:43

Lieutenant Richard Best takes his

31:45

division against Akagi.

31:47

Almost simultaneously, Leslie's Yorktown

31:49

bombers plunge towards Soryu. The

31:52

Japanese carriers recovering from

31:54

violent evasive maneuvers and with their

31:56

decks crowded with aircraft are caught

31:59

at their most vulnerable moment. On

32:02

Kaga, four bombs strike in rapid

32:04

succession. The first, a 1,000 pounder,

32:08

explodes near the bridge at 10:22,

32:10

killing Captain Jasaku Okarda and most

32:13

of his command staff instantly. The

32:15

second strikes the flight deck amid

32:17

ships, penetrating to the hanger deck

32:19

where fueled aircraft explode in chain

32:21

reactions. The third and fourth bombs

32:24

turn the ship into an inferno. Within

32:27

minutes, Kaga is a floating torch with

32:29

ammunition cooking off and aviation fuel

32:31

creating walls of flame. A kagi takes

32:35

just one direct hit at 1,024 from

32:38

Lieutenant Best's bomb, but it's enough.

32:41

The 1,000lb bomb penetrates the flight

32:44

deck and explodes in the upper hanger

32:46

among 18 aircraft being refueled and

32:48

rearmed. The induced explosions of the

32:51

improperly stored ordinance are

32:53

catastrophic. Torpedoes detonate, bombs

32:57

explode, and aviation fuel creates an

33:00

unstoppable conflration.

33:02

Bridge personnel report that within 2

33:04

minutes, the entire hanger deck is an

33:06

inferno with temperatures exceeding

33:08

1,000° C.

33:11

Soru suffers three direct hits in her

33:13

hanger spaces at 10:25.

33:16

Lieutenant Leslie's bombers place their

33:18

ordinance with deadly precision. 13

33:21

valves, three zeros, and four Kates on

33:24

the flight deck are blown apart. Below

33:27

in the hangers, the stacked torpedoes

33:29

and bombs create secondary explosions

33:32

that tear through the ship's vitals. Her

33:34

captain, Ryusaku Yanagimoto, refuses to

33:38

leave his burning ship. According to the

33:40

testimony of Chief Petty Officer Abe,

33:43

who was sent to rescue him, Yanagamoto

33:45

was last seen on the bridge, sword in

33:48

hand, singing the national anthem,

33:50

Kimigayo, as flames engulfed the command

33:53

structure. Only Hiru, separated from the

33:56

others by several miles and screened by

33:58

clouds, escapes. Admiral Yamaguchi

34:02

immediately prepares a counter strike,

34:04

but 3/4 of Japan's carrier striking

34:06

power has been eliminated in 5 minutes.

34:09

At 1058, even as the three carriers

34:12

burn, Yamaguchi launches 18 Valdive

34:15

bombers and six zero escorts led by

34:18

Lieutenant Mitio Kobayashi.

34:21

Following the American planes return

34:23

track, they find Yorktown at 1200.

34:26

Despite fierce resistance from Wildcat

34:28

fighters and anti-aircraft fire, they

34:31

score three bomb hits, leaving the

34:33

American carrier dead in the water,

34:35

burning and listing. Damage control

34:38

parties work frantically, and

34:40

incredibly, within 2 hours, Yorktown is

34:43

underway again, making 20 knots.

34:46

Yamaguchi, aggressive to the end,

34:49

immediately prepares a second strike. At

34:52

13:31, only 10 Kate torpedo bombers and

34:56

six zeros are available, led by

34:58

Lieutenant Tomminaga.

35:00

During the morning midway strike,

35:02

Tomminaga's left-wing fuel tank had been

35:05

damaged. Maintenance crews only had time

35:07

to fuel his right tank.

35:10

Offered a chance to switch planes,

35:12

Tomaga refused, stating every aircraft

35:15

was needed. He knows it's a one-way

35:18

mission. His fuel will only last for the

35:20

attack run. At 14:30, Tomminaga's small

35:24

force finds Yorktown, now making 19

35:27

knots after heroic damage control

35:29

efforts. American fighters tear into the

35:32

formation. Tomaga holds his course

35:35

despite his plane catching fire from

35:37

fighter attacks. According to American

35:40

witnesses, his burning aircraft

35:42

maintained its torpedo run until the

35:44

very last moment, releasing its torpedo

35:47

before crashing into the sea. Two

35:50

torpedoes hit Yorktown at 1445, tearing

35:53

open her port side and causing a 26°

35:57

list. This time, the damage is fatal.

36:00

But at 1700, 24 dive bombers from

36:03

Enterprise find Hiru. Four bombs turn

36:07

her into another inferno. At 1703,

36:10

Yamaguchi assembles his crew on the

36:12

tilting flight deck. According to

36:15

survivors, he apologized for the defeat,

36:18

urged them to survive and rebuild a

36:20

stronger navy, then retired to his

36:22

bridge with Captain Tomoko Kaku. Both

36:25

chose to go down with their ship. Their

36:27

bodies were never recovered.

36:30

Yamaguchi's final message to Nagumo

36:32

included an apology for the defeat and a

36:35

hope for the emperor's fortune in war.

36:38

He was postumously promoted to vice

36:40

admiral. Through the night of June 4th

36:42

to 5th, the surviving Japanese ships

36:45

attempt damage control, but it's

36:47

hopeless. Soryu sinks at 1913 on the 4th

36:51

with 711 men. Kaga follows at 1925,

36:56

taking 811 sailors to the bottom. At

37:00

0200 on June 5th, Yamamoto, still 600 m

37:05

away aboard his flagship Yamato with the

37:07

main body that never engaged, finally

37:10

accepts reality. He signals, "Occupation

37:14

of Midway is canled. Withdraw."

37:18

Akagi proves surprisingly hard to kill.

37:21

Despite the raging fires, she remains

37:23

afloat through the night. At 0500 on

37:27

June 5th, after all survivors are

37:29

evacuated, Japanese destroyers fire four

37:32

torpedoes into her. She finally sinks,

37:35

taking 267 men with her. Hiu, also

37:39

refusing to die easily, is scuttled at

37:42

0510. After burning through the night,

37:45

she takes 392 sailors and both her

37:49

admirals into the deep. As the sun rises

37:52

on June 5th, the cream of the Imperial

37:54

Japanese Navy's carrier force lies on

37:57

the bottom of the Pacific in water over

37:59

17,000 ft deep. With them are 3,57 men.

38:05

Of these, 2,181

38:08

died on the carriers. A Kagi lost 267.

38:12

Kaga 811, Hiru 392, and Soryu 711.

38:19

Another 792 died on the heavy cruisers

38:22

when Makuma was sunk, 700 dead, and

38:26

Moami damaged, 92 dead, after they

38:29

collided during night operations and

38:31

were caught by American aircraft.

38:34

Crucially, only 110 were air crew. Most

38:37

pilots were rescued. The greater

38:40

irreplaceable loss was over 700 skilled

38:43

aircraft mechanics and flight deck

38:45

personnel whose expertise had taken

38:47

years to develop.

38:49

The survivors picked up by destroyers

38:52

are immediately segregated from the rest

38:54

of the fleet to prevent news of the

38:56

disaster from spreading. They are

38:58

confined below decks, forbidden to

39:01

communicate with anyone. The disaster

39:03

isn't quite over. On June 6th, the

39:06

submarine I168

39:08

commanded by Lieutenant Commander

39:10

Yahachi Tanab finds the crippled

39:13

Yorktown Undertoe by USS Vero. Tonab had

39:17

been off midway providing weather

39:19

reports and had watched the morning

39:20

attacks through his periscope. Now

39:23

slipping through the destroyer screen at

39:25

3 knots, he achieves what the entire

39:27

Kido Bhutai could not.

39:30

At 1331, Tanabay fires a spread of four

39:33

torpedoes from 1,200 yds. Two hit

39:38

Yorktown. One hits the destroyer Hammond

39:40

alongside, providing auxiliary power.

39:43

Hammond breaks in two and sinks in 4

39:46

minutes with 80 dead, many killed by her

39:48

own depth charges exploding. Yorktown,

39:52

hit by two more torpedoes, is doomed,

39:54

but refuses to sink immediately. She

39:57

finally rolls over and sinks at 0701 on

40:00

June 7th in approximately 16,650

40:04

ft of water. This small consolation

40:08

sinking the carrier that had helped

40:09

destroy the Kido Bhutai barely registers

40:12

against the scale of the Japanese

40:14

defeat. Meanwhile, the heavy cruisers

40:16

Magami and Mikuma attempting to bombard

40:19

Midway on the night of June 4th had

40:22

collided while avoiding submarine

40:23

attack. American aircraft find them on

40:27

June 6th.

40:29

Makuma is sunk with 700 hands, the

40:32

highest death toll of any Japanese ship

40:34

at midway. Moami, heavily damaged and

40:37

with 92 dead, barely makes it back to

40:40

Trrook. The disaster is complete. The

40:44

journey home is one of shame and

40:45

silence. Wounded sailors from the

40:48

carriers are kept isolated in special

40:50

compartments. No one is allowed to speak

40:53

of what happened.

40:55

When the fleet returns to Japan at

40:57

Hashiima Naval Base on June 14th, they

41:00

anchor at night to avoid observation.

41:03

The wounded are offloaded in darkness,

41:05

classified as secret patients, and taken

41:08

to isolated naval hospitals where

41:10

they're kept under virtual arrest,

41:12

quarantined even from their own

41:13

families. They are forbidden any contact

41:16

with the outside world. According to US

41:19

Naval Institute sources, they were

41:21

treated in an appalling manner as

41:23

disgraced losers.

41:25

The survivors of the air groups are

41:27

immediately reassigned to distant bases

41:29

in the South Pacific without being

41:31

allowed to see families or friends. The

41:34

majority will die in the subsequent

41:36

battles of the Solomon Islands campaign.

41:39

The carrier crews are dispersed to

41:41

different ships and bases sworn to

41:43

secrecy under threat of severe

41:45

punishment. The systematic cover up

41:48

begins immediately. The government

41:50

prepares its propaganda. The sunken

41:53

carriers are Kagi and Hiryu remain on

41:55

the official roster as unmanned to

41:58

maintain the fiction they still exist.

42:01

No flag officers are caught marshaled or

42:03

even officially reprimanded as this

42:05

would require admitting defeat.

42:07

Information about the defeat is withheld

42:10

from the Imperial Japanese Army for a

42:12

full month. Even Prime Minister Hideki

42:14

Tojo is kept in the dark about the full

42:17

extent of the disaster.

42:19

On June 5th, while the ship still

42:21

burned, Tokyo radio had announced to the

42:24

Japanese people, "Naval and air forces

42:27

of the Empire have succeeded in

42:29

inflicting heavy damage on American

42:31

fleet and air forces in the Central

42:33

Pacific." Later broadcasts added that

42:36

Japan had achieved another smashing

42:38

victory with two American carriers sunk.

42:42

As an aside mentioned almost in passing,

42:45

the loss of one carrier Kaga was

42:47

acknowledged with Soryu's loss admitted

42:50

later. Akagi and Hiru's destruction

42:53

would not be publicly acknowledged until

42:55

after the war. The Japanese people

42:58

celebrated in the streets, unaware they

43:00

were cheering a catastrophe.

43:03

It wasn't until June 10th that the Tokyo

43:06

press first hinted at problems, using

43:08

vague language about difficulties in the

43:10

operation, but still maintaining the

43:13

fiction of overall victory. Commander

43:16

Fuchida recuperating in the hospital

43:18

from his appendecttomy and burns

43:20

received during Akagi's destruction, is

43:23

visited by a naval intelligence officer

43:25

who warns him, "You are forbidden to

43:27

speak of what happened. As far as the

43:30

world knows, we won a great victory.

43:33

According to postwar accounts that must

43:35

be treated cautiously given questions

43:37

about Fuida's reliability, he responded

43:40

with bitter irony about the futility of

43:42

building a war on lies. Though this

43:45

exchange cannot be independently

43:47

verified,

43:48

Admiral Yamamoto returns to his cabin

43:50

aboard Yamato and doesn't emerge for 3

43:53

days. His staff hears him pacing at

43:56

night, tortured by his failure. To his

43:59

diary, he confides thoughts that would

44:01

only be discovered after the war.

44:03

According to staff officers who served

44:05

with him, Yamamoto fell into deep

44:08

depression, knowing the war was now

44:10

unwinable. His prediction to Prime

44:12

Minister Konoy had proven prophetic.

44:15

Japan had indeed run wild for 6 months,

44:19

exactly as he had foreseen.

44:22

Now at Midway, occurring precisely 6

44:24

months after Pearl Harbor, the tide had

44:27

turned.

44:28

In a private meeting with his staff

44:30

documented by Captain Kurroshima,

44:33

Yamamoto was brutally frank. I gambled

44:36

and lost. In trying to destroy the

44:39

American carriers, I have lost our own.

44:42

The war is not lost yet, but I fear I

44:45

have lost the means to win it.

44:47

To his close friend, Rear Admiral

44:50

Teichi,

44:51

he would later write a letter that

44:53

survived the war. The defeat at Midway

44:56

was not a matter of bad luck or enemy

44:58

superiority in numbers. It was the

45:00

result of our own overconfidence and

45:02

poor planning. We underestimated

45:05

American capabilities and overestimated

45:07

our own. Now we will pay the price for

45:10

our hubris. I give Japan perhaps 18

45:13

months before the situation becomes

45:15

completely hopeless. His prediction

45:18

would prove optimistic. Within 18

45:20

months, Japan would lose the Maranas,

45:23

and American B-29s would be within range

45:26

of the home islands. The true cost of

45:29

Midway extends far beyond the four

45:31

carriers and 3,57 dead. Japan has lost

45:35

over 100 of its best pilots, men with

45:38

years of training and combat experience

45:40

from China to the Indian Ocean. The

45:43

pilot training program which takes 2

45:45

years minimum to produce a combat ready

45:48

aviator and far longer to create an

45:50

expert cannot replace them. More

45:53

critically, the 700 plus skilled

45:56

aircraft mechanics, armorers, and flight

45:58

deck crew who died represent

46:00

institutional knowledge that took

46:02

decades to develop. These men knew every

46:05

rivet of their aircraft, every quirk of

46:08

their carriers operations. As Admiral

46:10

Ugaki writes in his diary, later

46:13

captured and translated, "We can build

46:16

new carriers in two years. We cannot

46:18

build new pilots with the experience of

46:21

those we lost. And we will never replace

46:23

the skilled maintenance crews who knew

46:25

how to keep our aircraft flying under

46:28

combat conditions.

46:30

The real tragedy of Midway is not the

46:32

ships, but the men.

46:34

The Japanese naval aviation never

46:37

recovers. At the Battle of the

46:39

Philippine Sea 2 years later in June

46:41

1944,

46:43

inexperienced Japanese pilots will be

46:45

massacred in what Americans call the

46:48

Great Mariana's Turkey Shoot. Japanese

46:51

naval aviators flying against veteran

46:54

American pilots in Superior Aircraft,

46:56

lose over 600 planes while inflicting

46:59

minimal damage. The seeds of that

47:02

disaster were planted in the waters off

47:04

Midway. Midway marks the end of Japanese

47:07

expansion.

47:09

Within the Imperial General

47:11

Headquarters, the reality slowly sinks

47:13

in. Despite the propaganda, the planned

47:16

invasions of Fiji, Samoa, and Hawaii are

47:19

quietly cancelled. The proposed

47:21

operation FS to cut the supply lines

47:24

between America and Australia is

47:26

abandoned. Instead, Japan is forced into

47:29

a defensive war it cannot win. The

47:32

Americans, their confidence soaring,

47:34

begin planning their counter offensive.

47:37

Guadal Canal, just two months away, will

47:40

begin the long, bloody American advance

47:42

toward Japan. The psychological impact

47:46

is equally devastating. The Japanese

47:48

Navy's aura of invincibility, carefully

47:51

cultivated since the victory over Russia

47:53

at Tsushima in 1905, is shattered

47:57

forever. As one destroyer captain,

48:00

Commander Tamichihara, recalled in his

48:02

memoirs, "After Midway, we never felt

48:05

confident again. We went into battle

48:08

expecting to lose. The Americans went in

48:11

expecting to win. The whole psychology

48:13

of the war had changed in those 5

48:15

minutes when our carriers were hit."

48:18

Within the Navy itself, bitter

48:20

recriminations begin immediately, though

48:22

never publicly. Admiral Nagumo made a

48:26

scapegoat for the defeat despite

48:27

following Orthodox doctrine is relegated

48:30

to shore duty. He will never command

48:33

carriers again. In 1944, during the

48:36

American invasion of Saipan, where he

48:38

commands ground forces, he commits

48:41

suicide rather than face capture.

48:43

Admiral Ugaki writes in his diary,

48:46

"Nagumo is finished as a commander. The

48:50

blame must fall on someone and it cannot

48:52

be Yamamoto.

48:54

The defeat also exposes fundamental

48:57

flaws in Japanese military culture. The

48:59

inflexibility of thinking, the inability

49:02

to adapt to unexpected situations, the

49:05

blind adherence to doctrine even when

49:07

circumstances change. All these cultural

49:10

traits that contributed to the defeat

49:12

are recognized but cannot be changed.

49:15

The same rigid hierarchy and thinking

49:18

that led to disaster at Midway will be

49:20

repeated again and again throughout the

49:22

war. Postwar analysis reveals the

49:25

cascade of failures that led to

49:27

disaster. The Japanese operation was too

49:30

complex with forces scattered across

49:33

thousands of miles unable to support

49:35

each other. Radio silence maintained

49:38

religiously prevented any coordination

49:40

when plans went arry. Intelligence was

49:43

abysmal. The Japanese had no idea

49:46

American carriers were already at sea,

49:48

while the Americans knew every detail of

49:50

Japanese plans thanks to their

49:52

codebreaking. The failure of

49:54

reconnaissance was particularly damning.

49:57

Only seven search planes to cover a vast

49:59

ocean area compared to over 30 American

50:02

PBY Catalinas. The canceled operation K

50:06

reconnaissance of Pearl Harbor due to

50:08

American presence at French frigate

50:10

Scholes. The submarine Cordon arriving

50:13

too late to detect American carriers

50:15

leaving Pearl Harbor. The tone's crucial

50:17

half-hour delay in launching its scout

50:20

plane.

50:21

Each failure individually might not have

50:23

been fatal. Together, they guaranteed

50:26

disaster. Perhaps most critically, the

50:29

Japanese underestimated American

50:31

capabilities while overestimating their

50:33

own. They assumed Americans couldn't

50:36

break their codes. They had. They

50:39

assumed Yorktown couldn't be repaired

50:41

quickly. She was fixed in 72 hours. They

50:45

assumed American pilots were inferior.

50:47

At Midway, American dive bomber pilots

50:50

proved devastatingly effective. They

50:53

assumed American carriers would arrive

50:55

after Midway was captured. They were

50:57

waiting in ambush. The damage control

50:59

failures were equally telling. Japanese

51:02

carriers with enclosed hanger decks and

51:04

inadequate firefighting systems became

51:07

death traps when hit. American carriers

51:10

with open hanger decks and superior

51:12

damage control proved far more

51:14

survivable. Yorktown took tremendous

51:17

punishment and might have survived if

51:19

not for the submarine attack. The

51:21

Japanese carriers burned

51:23

catastrophically from single hits due to

51:25

poor fuel system design and inadequate

51:27

ammunition handling procedures.

51:30

Admiral Yamamoto does not long survive

51:32

the defeat he knew doomed Japan. On

51:35

April 18th, 1943,

51:38

American codereers intercept his travel

51:40

schedule. P38

51:43

lightning fighters intercept his plane

51:45

over Bugenville and shoot it down. His

51:48

death, exactly one year after the dittle

51:51

raid that had precipitated Midway, seems

51:53

almost poetic justice. Found in the

51:56

jungle, still strapped to his seat,

51:58

sword at his side, Yamamoto takes to his

52:01

grave the full knowledge of how Japan

52:03

lost the war in those five minutes at

52:06

Midway. Before his death, in one of his

52:08

last letters to a friend that survived

52:10

the war, Yamamoto reflected with

52:13

remarkable clarity.

52:15

At Midway, we learned that wars are not

52:17

won by spiritual strength alone. They

52:20

are one by intelligence, both kinds,

52:23

good information, and the wisdom to use

52:25

it properly. We had neither. We were too

52:28

proud to believe the Americans could be

52:30

waiting for us, too rigid to adapt when

52:32

our plans went wrong, and too arrogant

52:35

to admit our codes might be broken.

52:38

Pride goeth before a fall, and our pride

52:41

was limitless. The result was

52:43

inevitable.

52:45

The greatest irony of Midway is that it

52:47

achieved Yamamoto's goal just in

52:50

reverse. It was indeed the decisive

52:52

battle he had sought, but it was Japan,

52:55

not America, that was decisively

52:57

defeated. The carriers he had tried to

53:00

trap had instead trapped him. The ambush

53:03

he had planned became the ambush he

53:05

suffered. The decisive battle doctrine

53:07

that Japanese naval strategy had been

53:10

built upon for 40 years was proven

53:12

correct. But it was the Americans who

53:14

won it. As documented in Japanese

53:17

military archives, Yamamoto had

53:19

genuinely feared American industrial

53:21

might. In early 1942, he told his staff,

53:26

"A military man can scarcely pride

53:28

himself on having smitten a sleeping

53:30

enemy. It is more a matter of shame

53:32

simply for the one smitten. I would

53:35

rather you made your appraisal after

53:37

seeing what the enemy does, since it is

53:39

certain that angered and outraged, he

53:41

will soon launch a determined

53:43

counterattack.

53:45

At Midway, that counterattack arrived

53:47

with devastating efficiency. The

53:50

Americans had not only recovered from

53:52

Pearl Harbor, but had turned Japanese

53:54

strategy against them. The war would

53:57

continue for three more years, but its

53:59

outcome was effectively decided in those

54:02

5 minutes on June 4th, 1942.

54:05

But beyond the strategic implications,

54:08

Midway was fundamentally a human

54:10

tragedy. In the waters 325 mi northwest

54:14

of Midway, 3,57 Japanese sailors and

54:18

airmen died. young men who had written

54:21

final letters to their families that

54:23

morning, who had shared rice and tea for

54:26

breakfast, who had dreams of victory and

54:28

home. They died in flames that reached

54:31

1,000°,

54:33

drowned in oil sllicked waters, or were

54:35

torn apart by explosions that could be

54:38

heard miles away.

54:40

Lieutenant Hashimoto, one of the few

54:42

survivors from Akagi's engine room,

54:45

testified at postwar investigations.

54:48

The screams of burning men echo in my

54:50

nightmares still. We couldn't save them.

54:53

The passages were blocked by fire. The

54:56

ladders melted from heat. We could only

54:58

listen as they died. Their voices

55:00

calling for their mothers, for water,

55:03

for death to end their agony. Every

55:06

night I hear them still.

55:09

The families back home never learned the

55:11

truth during the war. They received

55:13

notices that their sons died gloriously

55:16

for the emperor in a great victory.

55:18

Mothers hung gold stars in their

55:21

windows, proud of their sacrifice, never

55:24

knowing it was for a defeat that sealed

55:26

Japan's fate. The truth would only

55:28

emerge after the war, adding betrayal to

55:31

grief. Many families refused to believe

55:34

it even then, so complete had been the

55:36

deception.

55:38

Petty Officer Tanaka, who survived

55:40

Soryu's sinking, recalled the morning

55:43

before the battle. We were so confident.

55:46

We joked about which American ship we

55:48

would sink. Yamada said he would sink a

55:51

battleship. Suzuki claimed he would

55:53

shoot down five American planes. They

55:56

were both 18 years old. Both died when

55:59

the bombs hit. Their bodies were never

56:01

recovered. Sometimes I wonder if they're

56:04

still down there, standing at their

56:06

posts, waiting for orders that will

56:08

never come. Today, the four Japanese

56:11

carriers rest in over 17,000 ft of

56:14

water. Their exact locations only

56:16

recently discovered by deep sea explorer

56:19

Robert Ballard and subsequent

56:21

expeditions.

56:22

They are war graves, monuments to the

56:25

price of hubris and the cost of war. The

56:28

aircraft that once launched from their

56:30

decks to spread destruction across the

56:32

Pacific lie crumpled in their hanger

56:34

bays. The bones of their crews remain at

56:37

their battle stations. Eternal guardians

56:40

of ships that will never sail again.

56:42

From the Japanese perspective, Midway

56:45

represents the moment when dreams of

56:46

empire collided catastrophically with

56:49

reality. It was proof that spiritual

56:52

strength alone cannot overcome material

56:54

weakness. that courage without

56:56

intelligence leads to disaster, that

56:59

rigid thinking cannot adapt to fluid

57:01

situations. It was Japan's appointment

57:04

with destiny, and destiny proved

57:07

merciless. The Midway defeat shattered

57:10

more than ships and lives. It shattered

57:12

illusions.

57:14

The myth of Japanese invincibility, the

57:17

faith in spiritual superiority over

57:19

material strength, the belief that

57:21

determination could overcome any odds,

57:24

all died with the carriers. In their

57:27

place came the grim recognition that

57:29

Japan had started a war it could not win

57:31

against an enemy it had fatally

57:33

underestimated, using strategies that

57:36

modern warfare had rendered obsolete.

57:39

Yet from the ashes of defeat came a

57:41

different Japan, one that renounced war,

57:44

embraced democracy and became a force

57:46

for peace and prosperity. The samurai

57:49

spirit that once drove conquest now

57:52

drives innovation.

57:54

The nation that once sought to dominate

57:56

the Pacific now helps maintain its

57:58

peace. The technological expertise that

58:01

once built carriers now builds cars and

58:03

computers. In that transformation,

58:06

perhaps the 3,57 who died at Midway did

58:10

not die entirely in vain. The battle

58:13

also stands as a warning to all nations

58:15

about the dangers of overconfidence and

58:17

rigid thinking. The Japanese military,

58:20

despite its tactical brilliance and

58:22

brave personnel, fell victim to its own

58:25

success. victory disease. The assumption

58:28

that what worked before will always

58:30

work, that the enemy will act as

58:32

expected, that superior spirit will

58:35

overcome material disadvantage, infected

58:38

decision-making at every level. The same

58:41

navy that had brilliantly executed the

58:43

Pearl Harbor attack 6 months earlier,

58:46

now bungled basic reconnaissance,

58:48

ignored intelligence warnings, and

58:50

walked into a trap that should have been

58:52

obvious. As we look back at Midway from

58:55

the Japanese perspective, we see not

58:57

villains, but human beings caught in the

59:00

terrible machinery of war. Young pilots

59:02

who flew to their deaths with courage,

59:04

if not wisdom. Commanders making

59:07

decisions with incomplete information

59:09

under impossible pressure. Mechanics

59:12

working frantically to prepare aircraft

59:14

they would never see again. Sailors

59:16

fighting fires that could not be

59:18

controlled, staying at their posts until

59:21

the end. Their story deserves to be told

59:24

not to glorify defeat or war, but to

59:27

remember the cost of military aggression

59:29

and the price of imperial ambition.

59:32

Lieutenant Commander Fuchida, despite

59:34

the questions about his postwar

59:36

reliability, perhaps captured something

59:39

essential when he became a Christian

59:40

evangelist after the war and spent his

59:43

remaining years preaching

59:44

reconciliation.

59:46

Though his specific accounts must be

59:48

treated cautiously, his transformation

59:50

from architect of Pearl Harbor to

59:52

advocate for peace represents the

59:54

journey Japan itself took from

59:56

aggression to pacifism, from empire to

59:59

democracy, from isolation to

60:01

international cooperation.

60:04

The lesson of Midway from the Japanese

60:06

perspective is ultimately that no

60:08

nation, no matter how powerful, can

60:11

afford to underestimate its enemies,

60:13

overestimate its capabilities, or ignore

60:16

the changing realities of warfare. The

60:19

same carriers that had seemed invincible

60:21

at Pearl Harbor proved fatally

60:23

vulnerable at Midway. The same pilots

60:25

who had swept all before them met their

60:27

match in American dive bombers. The same

60:30

strategies that had worked against

60:32

divided enemies failed against a united

60:35

and informed opponent. In the end, the

60:38

waters that closed over the Japanese

60:40

carriers at Midway were the same waters

60:42

that would eventually wash away the

60:44

militarism that sent them there.

60:46

The young men who died believed they

60:49

were fighting for their emperor and

60:50

empire. They could not know they were

60:53

actually dying for the birth of a new

60:55

Japan, peaceful, prosperous, and

60:57

democratic. Their sacrifice, though

61:00

tactically meaningless and strategically

61:02

disastrous, helped demonstrate the

61:04

futility of military aggression and the

61:07

impossibility of sustaining empire

61:09

through force.

61:11

This is the battle of Midway from the

61:13

Japanese perspective, a story of pride

61:16

before the fall, of human error

61:18

compounding into catastrophe, of young

61:21

lives sacrificed for strategic

61:23

miscalculation.

61:24

It's a story that deserves to be told,

61:27

not to celebrate defeat or victory, but

61:29

to remember the cost of war and the

61:31

price of empire. For in the end, the

61:34

waves that closed over the Japanese

61:36

carriers at Midway were the same waves

61:38

that would eventually wash clean the

61:40

stains of militarism, leaving behind a

61:43

nation transformed and a lesson for all

61:45

humanity. That the path of aggression

61:48

leads only to destruction, and that true

61:50

strength lies not in conquest, but in

61:53

peace.

61:54

The ghosts of Midway, Japanese and

61:57

American alike, remind us that war is

61:59

not glorious but terrible, not

62:01

triumphant but tragic, and that peace,

62:04

however difficult to maintain, is always

62:07

preferable to even the most decisive

62:09

victory. In the vast Pacific, where the

62:12

carriers still lie in their deep graves,

62:14

the only sound is the eternal movement

62:16

of the waves, carrying neither Japanese

62:19

nor American voices, but simply the echo

62:22

of humanity's costliest lesson, that

62:24

war, no matter who wins, leaves only

62:27

loss in its

UNLOCK MORE

Sign up free to access premium features

INTERACTIVE VIEWER

Watch the video with synced subtitles, adjustable overlay, and full playback control.

SIGN UP FREE TO UNLOCK

AI SUMMARY

Get an instant AI-generated summary of the video content, key points, and takeaways.

SIGN UP FREE TO UNLOCK

TRANSLATE

Translate the transcript to 100+ languages with one click. Download in any format.

SIGN UP FREE TO UNLOCK

MIND MAP

Visualize the transcript as an interactive mind map. Understand structure at a glance.

SIGN UP FREE TO UNLOCK

CHAT WITH TRANSCRIPT

Ask questions about the video content. Get answers powered by AI directly from the transcript.

SIGN UP FREE TO UNLOCK

GET MORE FROM YOUR TRANSCRIPTS

Sign up for free and unlock interactive viewer, AI summaries, translations, mind maps, and more. No credit card required.