TRANSCRIPTEnglish

The PROBLEM with Active Recall and Spaced Repetition (Truth Behind Studying Smarter)

41m 41s7,855 words1,191 segmentsEnglish

FULL TRANSCRIPT

0:08

so this video is going to be a little

0:11

bit controversial not because i want to

0:13

be controversial but

0:14

it just is if you're

0:16

really into active recall and space

0:19

repetition and if those are the

0:20

techniques that you think work the best

0:23

then

0:25

you're probably

0:27

wrong

0:28

let me explain why for those of you that

0:30

don't know i'm dr justin sung i'm a

0:33

medical doctor but i'm also more

0:35

importantly a learning coach it's what i

0:37

do full-time i work with students

0:40

teaching them evidence-based studying

0:42

and time management skills

0:56

before i tell you why active recoil and

0:58

space repetition doesn't really work let

1:00

me tell you a really quick story about

1:01

how i came to discover this

1:06

okay so rewind like 10 years ago and i'm

1:09

trying to enter into medical school i'm

1:11

still in high school right now and i'm

1:12

doing relatively okay i'm getting a high

1:14

grade band i'm getting some scholarships

1:17

i'm doing reasonably well you know

1:18

people used to look at me as a smart kid

1:20

i go into university during this year i

1:22

just studied and studied and studied

1:23

like non-stop that's all i did and in

1:26

this first year of uni this is where i

1:27

really started getting into active

1:29

recoil and space repetition it was all

1:30

the hype monsters or the hype i had

1:33

thousands of flash cards and i would

1:35

study literally

1:38

every day

1:40

all day when i say all day i was only

1:43

getting like two or three hours of sleep

1:44

every night um it was very very bad and

1:48

i did that every single day every single

1:49

weekend uh for about nine to ten

1:52

consecutive months it was pretty brutal

1:54

um i was incredibly sleep deprived

1:56

obviously i was hallucinating even i

1:59

remember one time where i had been awake

2:01

for like i think i was awake for like 77

2:03

hours and i was probably studying like

2:05

70 of those hours i would study when i

2:07

was eating i would study while i was

2:09

brushing my teeth i would study in the

2:10

shower

2:12

my entire day was just filled with

2:13

studying uh obviously i was a little bit

2:15

obsessed

2:16

and i did end up getting very very good

2:18

grades um and i ended up getting into

2:21

medical school so what happened when i

2:22

entered into medical school well the

2:24

thing is the thing is that when you

2:25

enter into medical school right so

2:28

before getting in i was studying about

2:30

this much okay that year i essentially

2:32

memorized this whole textbook i'm

2:34

probably a little bit more for the other

2:35

subjects as well

2:36

but when i got into medical school i

2:38

realized that there was a a lot more

2:41

that i needed to learn and in fact the

2:43

content was about double i needed to

2:45

study about double so for those of you

2:47

that are pretty good at maths you'll

2:49

know that um you can't study more than

2:52

like if you're studying 20 hours a day

2:54

you can't study 40 hours a day no matter

2:56

how lingling you are and that was

2:57

obviously a problem because i just

2:59

entered into medical school and i didn't

3:00

want to

3:01

fail so i had to figure out a better way

3:04

to study so that's when i started

3:05

looking into effective study techniques

3:07

and what really got me was that i was

3:09

spending a lot of time doing my flash

3:11

cards and space repetition and active

3:13

recon all of that sort of stuff and it

3:15

wasn't really getting the type of

3:16

results that i wanted there were guys in

3:18

my class who

3:20

i

3:20

like never saw studying and they would

3:23

consistently outperform me in the in my

3:25

tests and exams it was pretty

3:26

frustrating so i looked into the

3:28

research and i started experimenting

3:29

with different ways that i could study

3:31

and i did this like a crazy person like

3:33

my life depended on it because my

3:36

livelihood did i didn't want to spend my

3:37

whole life just sitting in a library

3:39

wasting away and everything i learned i

3:41

taught to other students by the time i

3:43

finished my third year of uni i'd

3:44

already gotten a teaching certificate so

3:47

i'd learn a lot more about the theory

3:48

behind learning and how that works and

3:50

that allowed me to learn even more

3:51

deeply okay fast forward a few years i'd

3:53

actually built an entire business around

3:56

teaching students and one of the things

3:57

that i learned while i was teaching

3:58

other students was that there are some

4:00

techniques that will work as long as

4:02

you're already pretty good at studying

4:04

if you're not someone that is like very

4:07

uh good at what's called deep processing

4:10

um you know essentially someone that can

4:11

just pick up a new concept and learn it

4:13

really really quickly to begin with then

4:16

a lot of the techniques don't actually

4:18

work or it's not enough and so for for

4:21

me as essentially a learning

4:23

professional teaching others and getting

4:25

paid to help them learn to learn i had

4:27

to figure out a way to help students to

4:30

do well even if they weren't already you

4:32

know like a genius

4:34

and this is kind of where the story

4:35

begins because it's been 10 years and

4:38

i've learned a lot so

4:40

hear me out on this so the first thing

4:42

that i want to say is that i know that

4:45

what i'm going to say today goes in the

4:46

face of maybe everything that you've

4:47

heard from your friends or your teachers

4:49

or your parents or other people on

4:51

youtube i know and i get it when i teach

4:54

you

4:54

uh what i've learned it's gonna make

4:56

sense to you as well okay but there is a

4:58

lot to cover there's a lot of stuff i'm

5:00

gonna go through that you've probably

5:02

never heard before so uh

5:04

before we understand why active recoil

5:07

and space repetition doesn't work as

5:09

well as people hype it up to

5:12

we first need to understand a little bit

5:14

about

5:14

how learning actually works in the first

5:16

place because without knowing that we're

5:18

not going to understand where it works

5:20

and then where it fails and that's going

5:21

to be really important for you to look

5:23

at your own studying system and actually

5:25

start tweaking it if you don't know why

5:26

it works in the first place every time

5:28

you have an issue you are not going to

5:29

know how to problem solve and i think

5:31

that's very important to know so the

5:32

first thing i want to point out is that

5:34

studying

5:35

is not the same thing as learning and

5:38

this may be something that is really

5:40

obvious to you

5:41

but i found that a lot of students have

5:43

not ever thought about this is the fact

5:45

that studying is actually this process

5:47

that we are doing physically

5:50

right it could be the writing of notes

5:52

when we're um you know in class or

5:55

revising material it could be us

5:57

watching a video about something

6:00

right now you might be studying this

6:02

video as you're listening this is the

6:04

stuff we do out in the physical world uh

6:07

and the purpose of doing this

6:09

is so that we can get

6:12

learning occurring so the purpose of

6:14

studying is to produce

6:16

learning and learning is actually the

6:18

cognitive

6:19

process that occurs

6:21

and this is essentially when information

6:24

is connected into our brain and we can

6:27

say that we have learned successfully if

6:29

that knowledge is retained

6:31

and preferably we are actually able to

6:34

use it and apply this knowledge so

6:37

learning and studying are two separate

6:38

things so if you were to take a textbook

6:41

and then you would smash your face into

6:42

the textbook

6:43

you would not say that that is either

6:45

studying or learning but if you were to

6:47

smash your face into the textbook enough

6:49

times you will at the very least have

6:51

learned the name of the title of the

6:53

textbook as it comes into your face

6:56

repeatedly

6:58

that's not the best wording that i could

7:00

have used for that as it impacts your

7:02

face repeatedly

7:04

and so in this example we have actually

7:06

learned something so if your friend were

7:08

to say hey how are you going to study

7:09

for that test and you say oh you know

7:10

just the usual slamming the textbook

7:12

into my face then that would be your

7:14

studying technique i guess now that's an

7:16

extreme example well what about if you

7:18

were to open up the textbook and then

7:19

you were to touch the pages what if you

7:21

would have flicked the pages what if you

7:22

were to look at the pages while you were

7:24

flicking them what if you would have

7:25

read the words on the pages what if you

7:27

were to read slowly

7:29

what if you were to then read it and

7:30

then write something so you see how

7:32

changing different things about the

7:34

activity changes the amount of learning

7:35

that it engages so it shows that the

7:37

learning process is something that is

7:39

activated by the studying process and

7:41

not all studying processes activate the

7:44

same amount of learning so that means

7:46

that you can potentially spend 10 hours

7:49

studying using one technique and then

7:51

get only one hour of learning if your

7:54

technique is only let's say 10 efficient

7:56

now in reality it's really hard to put

7:58

these exact percentage numbers on it

8:00

because it's just really hard to measure

8:01

but you get the gist some techniques are

8:03

really efficient you can get a lot of

8:05

learning in your brain done using them

8:08

some techniques are less efficient and

8:10

broadly speaking we call the techniques

8:13

that are more effective at

8:15

learning active learning techniques and

8:18

there is a huge

8:20

range of active learning techniques that

8:23

we can use while we're studying so what

8:25

is it that is actually happening in our

8:26

brain when we say that this learning

8:28

thing is encoding okay so let me give

8:30

you a very quick dive into how our

8:32

memory actually works

8:34

there's this one model for our memory

8:36

that is called the multi-store

8:38

model of memory

8:41

and this can get pretty complicated but

8:42

long story short it says that there are

8:45

different places in our memory where the

8:46

information goes number one when we take

8:49

an information it comes in a sensory

8:51

information so this is the type of stuff

8:53

that we might be seeing with our eyes or

8:56

listening with our ears right now you're

8:58

receiving sensory information and this

9:00

goes into a part of our brain which is

9:01

called the sensory memory so that's

9:03

relatively straightforward now

9:05

information from your sensory memory is

9:07

forgotten very very quickly

9:10

because if you imagine holding on to

9:12

every piece of information that you are

9:14

bombarded with on a daily basis and

9:17

remembering all of that your brain would

9:19

just explode

9:21

imagine remembering every single

9:22

sensation that is on your skin every

9:25

license plate you see as you're walking

9:27

that would be incredibly overwhelming

9:29

but more importantly it's very energy

9:31

inefficient if we don't need that

9:33

information it's not going to keep it in

9:35

fact it's a life or death situation from

9:37

your body's point of view your brain

9:38

consumes already at rest around 20 of

9:41

your resting energy caloric intake per

9:43

day so what that means is that if it's

9:45

unnecessarily being super active holding

9:48

on to irrelevant information you will

9:50

literally die

9:54

so the point is that your brain is

9:56

really really efficient at forgetting

9:57

anything that is not relevant and not

10:00

necessary what happens after this is

10:02

that if you intend to keep this

10:05

information if you want to remember it

10:07

for longer then it shuts this

10:09

information into something that is

10:10

called the working memory now this is

10:13

also sometimes called the short term

10:15

memory but i like calling it the working

10:16

memory because it also talks about one

10:18

of its other functions which is that

10:20

when you have information that's in your

10:21

long-term memory and you want to use it

10:24

again it has to go through the work

10:25

working memory first so here's how this

10:27

works some of this information that

10:30

initially came in through sensory

10:32

pathways goes into our working memory

10:34

and then from our working memory goes

10:36

into our long term

10:39

memory here and this is a process that

10:41

we call encoding

10:44

now when we want to use this information

10:46

we have to retrieve it from our

10:48

long-term memory and this is a process

10:50

that's called retrieval so that means

10:52

that every time you are answering a test

10:55

question or an exam paper or someone

10:58

asks you a question about anything

11:00

what we're trying to do is we're trying

11:02

to collect it from our long-term memory

11:04

call it forth into our working memory

11:06

and that's where we can actually answer

11:08

or manipulate the information or do

11:10

something with it so i like thinking

11:11

about the working memory almost like a

11:13

hotel lobby

11:14

you can stay there for a short period of

11:16

time but you're going to get kicked out

11:18

if you don't have a room in the hotel

11:20

but to get in and out of this building

11:22

you need to pass through the lobby no

11:24

matter what so the working memory is

11:27

where you're going to be spending a lot

11:28

of your time when you're manipulating

11:29

the information but it's not a good

11:31

place to hold on to it because the

11:33

working memory will also forget

11:34

information relatively quickly in the

11:37

span of sort of seconds to minutes

11:40

now your long-term memory is a little

11:41

bit different your long-term memory will

11:43

forget things as well

11:45

but it will forget things much more

11:47

slowly it will forget things in the span

11:49

of hours to even months

11:51

and it depends on how strongly it was

11:54

encoded in this process here and that is

11:58

very very complicated i'm not going to

11:59

be able to get into it and we also don't

12:01

fully know exactly all the things that

12:04

that involves but we do know a few

12:06

things due to extensive research in this

12:08

field and one of those things is that

12:10

encoding and retrieval are both very

12:12

very important you can't just encode

12:14

because then your brain doesn't know how

12:16

to retrieve it properly to actually

12:18

answer the questions but also you can't

12:20

retrieve

12:22

what you don't encode you can't pour

12:25

from an empty bucket if you don't fill

12:27

it in the first place or if your bucket

12:29

has holes then when you need to pour

12:32

stuff out of it nothing's going to come

12:34

out so there are two sides of the same

12:36

coin and students often don't think much

12:39

about the encoding process and that's

12:40

because of another thing that we know

12:42

about encoding which is the fact that

12:44

encoding uses

12:46

a lot of what we call

12:47

cognitive

12:49

load and cognitive load is in short the

12:53

brain power

12:54

necessary to do the encoding process

12:58

encoding does not happen without

13:01

sufficient cognitive load now cognitive

13:04

load is also something that is actually

13:06

pretty complicated and a lot of places

13:08

teach it wrong i've even advised at

13:11

schools where their own school

13:13

curriculum taught cognitive load

13:16

incorrectly but again the long story

13:18

short here is that your brain has a

13:21

certain amount of load that it can kind

13:22

of tolerate and this is something that

13:25

can actually be trained so if you aren't

13:27

able to tolerate a lot of this brain

13:29

power and a lot of this load then you

13:31

can actually train that which i will

13:33

talk about in other videos but

13:34

essentially what happens is that when

13:36

the load increases

13:38

your learning actually

13:41

increases as well

13:42

up to a certain point so what happens is

13:45

if this red line is talking about the

13:47

amount of cognitive load that you've got

13:49

on your brain and this green line is

13:51

talking about the amount of learning

13:53

that's occurring aka the amount of

13:54

encoding that is incurring then what we

13:57

see is that the amount of learning is

13:59

really low at low levels of cognitive

14:01

load and it goes up as the load goes up

14:04

to a certain extent once it reaches that

14:07

threshold

14:08

it actually starts to plateau and go

14:10

down so if we've got too much load then

14:13

we're overwhelmed and we're not learning

14:15

effectively but if we don't have enough

14:17

we're actually just fundamentally not

14:19

encoding it at all and all of the

14:21

techniques that result in very low

14:24

cognitive load and therefore very low

14:26

encoding and therefore very low learning

14:28

and therefore making you forget the same

14:31

thing that you studied 20 times very

14:33

very quickly

14:34

these are all called passive learning

14:37

and the thing is that this is something

14:39

that happens in your brain you can use

14:40

the same technique such as reading a

14:43

book but if you're thinking about it

14:45

differently you could get a lot of

14:47

learning out of it or you might be

14:49

completely passive so it's hard to tell

14:51

based on just looking at someone

14:53

studying or seeing what technique

14:55

they're using how much cognitive load is

14:57

actually going on inside their brain and

15:00

research is strongly supportive that the

15:02

relationship between cognitive load and

15:04

encoding and how good your memory and

15:06

retention is is very strongly associated

15:09

with the amount of load so the more load

15:12

the better to a certain point so what

15:14

does this cognitive load actually feel

15:16

like when you're studying cognitive load

15:19

feels

15:20

confusing it feels like you're already

15:22

trying to figure this out you might have

15:24

a little bit of cognitive load right now

15:26

thinking what is he talking about where

15:28

is this going how does that fit in how

15:30

do i apply that to my life how does that

15:33

how is it similar or different to what

15:36

else i know these questions this

15:38

confusion this is cognitive load and

15:40

this is a sign that your brain is

15:42

engaging high efficiency learning

15:45

pathways which means that if you're

15:46

studying and this isn't happening in

15:49

your brain

15:50

you're not getting that cognitive load

15:52

and another thing that we know is that

15:54

when this is happening in your brain

15:55

it's directly opposed to feeling

15:59

bored or or drowsy so if you've ever

16:01

been studying and you just find it so

16:03

boring and tedious and you're getting

16:04

sleepy and every time you start studying

16:06

you fall asleep that's what used to

16:08

happen to me all the time in fact i

16:10

probably got more sleep while i just

16:13

took naps while i was studying than i

16:15

did in my bed well if that's happening

16:18

then that is a sign that your studying

16:21

technique is actually not very efficient

16:23

because it means that you're not using

16:25

the right types of pathways in your

16:26

brain because if you were you actually

16:28

wouldn't feel that and there is studies

16:30

that's done on the electrical activity

16:32

of the brain that shows the different

16:33

waves and so right here this is one of

16:37

the main reasons why

16:39

techniques about encoding and this stuff

16:42

is not really talked about and you may

16:44

have never heard of this before

16:46

is because of the fact that learning

16:49

correct and coding is difficult it's not

16:52

just difficult in that there are a lot

16:53

of steps and there's a very specific

16:55

pathway to allow you to do correct

16:57

encoding in my course where i work with

17:00

students intimately

17:01

it takes

17:02

months to build up someone's encoding to

17:05

a very very significant degree but it is

17:08

in essence

17:10

forcing yourself to become

17:13

smarter when your encoding goes up you

17:16

are

17:17

faster at studying you can just

17:19

understand concepts faster you can just

17:22

hold on to the information for longer

17:24

you don't need to revise it all the time

17:26

your confidence goes up and you just

17:28

start enjoying the studying process a

17:30

lot more but that takes a lot of effort

17:33

and you have to be very willing and

17:36

ready to accept the discomfort that

17:39

comes with this encoding process and in

17:42

fact

17:42

this whole idea that it's difficult and

17:45

it's uncomfortable

17:47

this is actually called

17:49

desirable difficulty and not many

17:53

students are willing to go through that

17:55

discomfort in order to learn the skills

17:58

much like how if you were to go to the

18:00

gym you're only getting an effective

18:01

workout if your muscles are feeling

18:03

pretty tired same thing here is that

18:05

your brain is only really being used

18:07

effectively if it has that level of

18:09

discomfort and cognitive load so on the

18:12

flip side that actually means that

18:14

retrieval techniques are easier to learn

18:17

and this is where active recall and

18:20

space repetition come in they're very

18:22

easy techniques to learn pretty much

18:24

anyone can pick it up it doesn't have

18:26

any real learning curve you can hear

18:28

about it and then 10 15 minutes later

18:30

pretty much just do it straight away and

18:32

there is going to be a benefit so

18:35

we're getting there we're gonna

18:37

understand now why it doesn't really

18:39

work beyond a certain point because the

18:41

reason active recall and space

18:43

repetition works in the first place is

18:46

by adjusting and working on this

18:48

forgetting curve

18:50

now the forgetting curve is a very

18:52

popular well-known

18:54

concept and it basically says that the

18:56

first time that you learn something if

18:58

this is time on the x-axis here and this

19:00

is the amount of knowledge that you have

19:02

in your head stored able to be recalled

19:05

on the y-axis the first time you learn

19:07

something you actually forget this

19:09

information

19:10

relatively quickly

19:12

now if you were to then revise this

19:14

information again let's say a few hours

19:17

later then you would then forget it a

19:19

little bit more slowly and so every time

19:22

you repeat this information you're going

19:24

to forget it slower and slower and

19:25

slower until this

19:28

curve starts plateauing so you can see

19:30

that the slope of this here is you know

19:33

pretty steep whereas over here it's not

19:36

so steep which indicates that we are

19:38

forgetting information a lot slower over

19:40

here than over here where we're

19:42

forgetting a lot of information very

19:43

quickly now research will say that after

19:45

one week of learning a fact

19:48

with your without doing any other type

19:50

of retrieval in between you can actually

19:52

forget around 60 percent of this

19:54

information 50 to 60 of it so that

19:57

effectively means that half of all the

19:58

studying that you did completely just

20:00

went to waste after just one week and to

20:03

be honest a lot of students are not

20:05

revising stuff at the end of every week

20:08

to begin with either so it's actually in

20:09

reality going to be a lot more of an

20:12

issue than this because you essentially

20:13

just study everything throughout the

20:14

year and then before your exams it's

20:16

like you're just studying it from fresh

20:17

you've forgotten everything and i'm sure

20:20

some of you can relate to that so what

20:21

active recoil and space repetition is

20:22

doing is it's actually moving you along

20:24

this forgetting curve so instead of

20:25

being on this line where the rate of

20:28

decay and that is the technical word for

20:30

this the rate of decay is

20:34

very very quick we're getting to this

20:36

slope here so we are moving and

20:39

progressing along each slope so that our

20:42

rate of knowledge decay is a lot slower

20:46

which is obviously a good thing and this

20:48

is why it works this is why space

20:51

repetition

20:52

will work for you

20:54

if you're not

20:56

doing it at all if you're already not

20:58

doing any type of retrieval if you're

21:00

not doing any type of repetition

21:02

and revision then it will help you it

21:06

will work but the thing is

21:09

it has

21:10

diminishing

21:11

returns in fact very rapidly

21:15

diminishing returns so for those of you

21:17

that aren't familiar the idea of

21:18

diminishing returns is that something

21:21

can be really good at the beginning but

21:24

then it's not so good later on so let's

21:28

say for example you need to organize

21:30

your room because it's a mess and you

21:31

can't find anything anywhere and every

21:33

time you're trying to find a sock it

21:34

takes you 30 minutes then it might take

21:36

you an hour to clean up and organize

21:39

your room a little bit and after an hour

21:41

sure it's not completely organized and

21:43

it's not the best it could possibly be

21:46

but now you can find your sock in just

21:48

30 seconds or less so there's been a

21:50

huge improvement

21:52

but now if you were to go and try to

21:54

organize it even more if you were to try

21:56

to get it perfect maybe right now it's

21:59

80 90 there but to go that extra 10

22:03

maybe now what you're gonna have to do

22:04

is organize all your books in

22:06

alphabetical order and then organize all

22:08

your socks by different colors and

22:10

fabrics and that might take you another

22:12

three or four hours and at the end of

22:15

the day it might only help you find your

22:17

sock faster by like five more seconds so

22:20

that's what diminishing returns would be

22:22

in that first hour of organizing we get

22:24

huge and rapid gains but then it's

22:27

slower and the gains that we're getting

22:29

for the amount of effort that we're

22:30

putting in is just not quite there so

22:32

the reason that active recall and space

22:34

repetition are so evidence-based is that

22:37

the research strongly shows that

22:40

students that don't use active recall

22:42

and space repetition do worse than the

22:44

students that do use it and that is

22:46

completely true you're going from a

22:48

situation that is bad

22:50

to

22:51

better but

22:52

from better there's a very big

22:55

difference between better and really

22:57

good or best so if you're a student

23:00

that's not aiming to go from failing to

23:03

just passing or doing relatively well

23:06

but you're actually a student that's

23:08

already doing relatively good but you

23:10

want to be excellent then you're going

23:12

to find that using active recoil and

23:14

space repetition if you're not using it

23:16

already will help you

23:18

but it's going to be very difficult to

23:21

get to those very top marks and so again

23:23

when you look at the research there

23:25

isn't really strong evidence to say that

23:28

for people that are already achieving

23:30

pretty well that doing more active

23:32

recall in space repetition helps them in

23:33

fact some research says it's the

23:34

opposite it actually makes it worse and

23:37

that's because of the fact that active

23:39

wrinkle in space repetition is

23:40

inherently

23:41

very repetitive in fact that's kind of

23:43

the whole reason it works is that it's

23:45

repetitive and you're always fighting

23:48

the forgetting curve

23:50

your brain is constantly trying to

23:52

forget this information and you are

23:53

forcibly putting it back in there saying

23:56

don't forget it don't forget it don't

23:58

forget it but you have to do that for

23:59

everything that you're learning and that

24:01

will stack up when you look at all the

24:03

different subjects that you're taking

24:04

all the different facts and all the

24:05

different concepts

24:06

you're gonna have to

24:07

repeat the same thing three four or five

24:10

times to keep it in your brain which

24:12

means that you have to do three four

24:13

five times the amount of studying and

24:15

revision to keep it in your brain

24:17

if you imagine that the first time you

24:19

learned something you could encode it

24:20

100

24:22

highest quality and you just don't

24:23

forget it for like six months then you

24:25

would probably find that it's really

24:27

easy to study for your exams because you

24:29

don't ever need to revise the

24:30

information now that

24:32

isn't possible but we can get a lot

24:34

closer to that than most students

24:36

realize in fact more than even most

24:39

teachers will realize and so this

24:41

experience of just repeating information

24:43

and maybe doing your flashcards over and

24:45

over again and constantly trying to use

24:47

space repetition and study things but

24:48

then still not getting the results that

24:50

you want this is probably a very

24:51

familiar experience to people and

24:52

actually a lot of the students that are

24:54

using space repetition active recall

24:56

based systems will find that it's not

24:58

actually working as well as it seems

25:00

like it should be working it's not

25:02

giving them the results that they've

25:03

kind of been promised that they expect

25:05

it to get it can be extremely monotonous

25:07

and incredibly tedious very very time

25:10

consuming and in fact actually pretty

25:11

demoralizing if you're not getting the

25:13

results so in fact what some of the

25:14

research will show is that if you were

25:16

to look at all the different people that

25:18

are using a technique that involves

25:20

space repetition or active recall like

25:22

active recall based space repetition

25:24

algorithm anki flash card you actually

25:27

find the majority of the people that use

25:28

that technique don't do well so what

25:30

that means is that it's actually a

25:32

really common technique that a lot of

25:34

people are using and only some people

25:36

are going to do well and those people

25:39

that will do well using that technique

25:42

probably already have a pretty good

25:45

inherent ability to encode now if you

25:48

want not one of those people that

25:50

already came into things with a high

25:52

level of encoding then you're going to

25:53

find that active record space repetition

25:55

might actually make your life harder

25:57

because you're having to spend so much

25:59

of your time just repeating and

26:01

relearning the same stuff that you

26:02

forgot and that's not necessary like i

26:04

said before you can actually train this

26:07

process you can train your brain to

26:10

become smarter you can train your brain

26:13

to encode information

26:15

more efficiently the first time you

26:17

learn it and this is because of

26:18

something called neuroplasticity

26:20

which essentially says that your brain

26:22

is the ability to remode and adapt and

26:25

become better and learn new things so if

26:27

you're not someone that is previously

26:29

really like book smart and academic and

26:31

you're not someone that's usually really

26:33

good at picking up concepts really

26:34

quickly you can actually train that and

26:36

you can not just train it a little bit

26:39

but you can completely just like

26:42

absolutely

26:44

massively shift to the point where some

26:46

of my students in the past have actually

26:49

had interviews with their teachers

26:51

because the teachers didn't understand

26:53

how they were suddenly doing so well

26:56

just think about that for a second i do

26:58

this day in day out for thousands of

27:00

students all across the world so it's

27:02

very very consistent i haven't really

27:04

ever encountered a single student that

27:08

couldn't be trained to do this literally

27:10

ever over the last

27:12

almost 10 years of me teaching this okay

27:15

but the purpose of this video is not to

27:17

pitch my course so if you're interested

27:18

and you want to just have like that

27:19

proof that hey this actually works it's

27:21

not just like some random theory that

27:23

this dude on youtube is talking out of

27:25

like just random thin air this is stuff

27:27

that's like real

27:29

life cemented an actual practice i've

27:31

got real students real data that shows

27:34

the stuff in fact i'm gearing up to

27:36

publish it in journals

27:37

then you can learn more about that but

27:40

anyway to summarize what we have said

27:43

right now is that your brain tends to

27:46

forget stuff very efficiently if it's

27:48

not encoded into your long-term memory

27:50

encoding takes cognitive load that's

27:52

confusing that's

27:54

uncomfortable but if you learn the

27:56

techniques to navigate that then what

27:58

happens is that your forgetting curve

28:00

actually just starts becoming a lot

28:02

flatter to begin with which means that

28:04

you just don't need to revise it so

28:07

often you can

28:09

cancel out some of those revisions and

28:11

that means that because you're just

28:12

fundamentally forgetting stuff a lot

28:14

slower you just don't need to revise as

28:17

much and it's just a huge time save

28:19

so at this point you may be thinking two

28:21

things number one well justin then how

28:23

do you do all this amazing encoding

28:25

magical super silver bullet technique

28:28

well

28:29

i will have other videos talking about

28:31

that because this video is already

28:32

getting pretty long and it's necessary

28:34

to explain why the whole active recoil

28:36

space repetition

28:38

like cult

28:39

is not as hyped up as

28:42

it really is in real life but because

28:45

again the encoding techniques are not

28:46

easy it's not something i can just smash

28:48

out through like a one minute tick tock

28:50

there's

28:51

really a lot of explanation that goes

28:52

into it so i will be having a lot of

28:55

other videos talking about encoding

28:58

techniques and going through

28:59

demonstrations and examples and work

29:02

throughs and all of that sort of stuff

29:04

to just prove

29:05

to you that it does actually work it's

29:08

not just you know me making stuff up but

29:11

the other thing that you may be thinking

29:13

or doubting is well justin if this is as

29:17

good as you say it is and this is like

29:19

the third eye of studying waking up

29:24

then

29:25

why have i not heard of this before why

29:27

does everyone else on youtube say that

29:29

active recall and space repetition are

29:31

god level tech i've actually i literally

29:33

saw a study guru say active recoil and

29:36

space repetition was a god level

29:38

technique i was vomited in my mouth why

29:39

is everyone else saying that there's a

29:41

few reasons and there's actually even

29:43

some studies done around why people

29:45

believe studying related myths and one

29:47

of those things is because of something

29:49

called the dunning-kruger effect and it

29:52

looks a little bit like this this is the

29:54

dunning-kruger graph and what you can

29:56

see here is that there is knowledge on

29:58

the x-axis and confidence on the y-axis

30:01

so when you don't know anything your

30:03

confidence is really low well zero

30:06

because you know you know nothing but

30:08

when you learn a little bit about

30:10

something compared to nothing that's a

30:12

lot more so your confidence

30:14

grows much much higher you become much

30:17

more confident in this thing and then

30:20

when you learn more and more and more

30:22

you realize actually man there's more to

30:25

this than i thought uh and then as you

30:28

just commit your life towards learning

30:29

this 10 20 years later you truly become

30:32

an expert and your confidence grows

30:33

again because you legitimately know a

30:35

lot so there's only two points in which

30:38

the confidence is really high and that

30:41

is after you've spent decades learning

30:43

about this or you've only learned a

30:46

little bit and you just don't know what

30:48

you don't know and this is the case just

30:52

objectively like it's just the fact i

30:55

don't want this to be insulting

30:57

really don't like i don't want this

30:59

video to have as much backlash as i

31:01

suspect it will have

31:03

but a lot of the study youtubers out

31:06

there

31:07

don't know a lot about how learning

31:11

actually

31:12

works or what goes on in the brain

31:15

it's a lot of that is just they've

31:18

watched other youtube videos and they

31:20

have tried a few things and they i don't

31:23

know got into medical school or law

31:25

school or something and they sort of

31:27

said hey it works let me make a youtube

31:28

video about it and so

31:30

learning is actually really really

31:32

complicated because i did all of that i

31:34

did well and then i used techniques and

31:36

then i got good grades and i got into

31:38

medical school and i graduated i became

31:40

a doctor i even did this whole business

31:41

thing on the side while i was doing that

31:43

all that stuff and

31:45

i realized the more i learned the less i

31:47

knew

31:48

really i had overestimated how much i

31:51

knew 10 years ago learning is

31:54

legitimately

31:56

really

31:57

really complicated to the point where

31:59

just one of those concepts that i've

32:01

talked about today i've actually done

32:03

whole like five hour workshops on just

32:05

one of those concepts and that it's it's

32:08

still just barely scratching the surface

32:09

for a lot of students active recoil and

32:11

space repetition of some of the first

32:13

techniques that they learn about

32:15

studying before that it's like turn your

32:17

phone off don't

32:19

listen to your favorite song while

32:22

you're studying don't study inside your

32:24

bed covers you know stuff like that just

32:26

simple tips and tricks of just straight

32:29

up don't do that that's a terrible idea

32:31

type of advice an active record space

32:33

repetition are often some of the first

32:34

actual techniques that someone will

32:37

learn and it's a good first technique to

32:40

learn because it's easy to use and it

32:42

does again produce benefit if you're not

32:44

doing it already but again statistically

32:46

speaking there's more people that use

32:48

that technique and don't do well than

32:50

people that use that technique and do

32:52

well and this leads me to the second

32:55

reason why you don't hear about it so

32:57

much which is success bias now the story

33:00

behind success bias says that there were

33:03

these planes in world war ii or

33:05

something that came back after their

33:07

raids and they found that the wings had

33:10

the most amount of bullet holes in them

33:13

so the military said okay well we should

33:15

put less armor around the cockpit area

33:19

because obviously that place is not

33:21

getting shot as much and then a military

33:24

statistician said no that would be a

33:26

terrible idea

33:28

the only reason that our planes that

33:30

we're seeing have more bullet holes on

33:32

the wings is because

33:33

all the planes that got shot in the

33:36

middle

33:37

never returned they all died

33:40

so when's the last time you saw a

33:43

youtube video

33:44

from someone talking about how they

33:47

failed and that's the thing is that when

33:49

you don't do well you're not super keen

33:51

on telling the world about it you're a

33:52

lot less likely to make a big youtube

33:54

video or grow a channel about

33:57

failing to use a technique so you don't

33:59

hear a lot of the stories of people

34:01

using these techniques and not doing

34:03

well

34:04

i on the other hand as someone that is

34:06

actually employed as a coach to help

34:08

students that tried to use techniques

34:10

and didn't work i get to see how many

34:13

times people are following this advice

34:15

and it's not producing those results the

34:17

number of times that students will use

34:19

techniques like active recoil and space

34:21

repetition and not do well is

34:24

overwhelmingly

34:26

more common than the students that will

34:28

use it and then do well and even for the

34:30

students that do well they usually come

34:32

back one or two years later when they're

34:34

later in uni or the content is more

34:36

difficult or there's just more to know

34:38

and they're saying it's no longer

34:40

sustainable because they're just

34:42

spending way too much time

34:43

or there's just too much content and

34:45

they're just not able to keep on top of

34:47

it they're falling behind and they're

34:48

not able to finish all of their flash

34:50

cards or however else they're using it

34:51

so because we're only seeing the success

34:53

stories we're led to believe that it's

34:56

more useful and more effective than it

34:59

actually is which leads me to the third

35:01

bias which is something called

35:03

availability bias and what this says is

35:07

that we will judge how legit something

35:09

is based on how commonly we encounter it

35:11

so if we encounter a bunch of different

35:13

people saying hey vaccines are dangerous

35:16

we will believe that vaccines are

35:17

dangerous the same can be said of

35:18

climate change the same can be said

35:20

about

35:21

flat earthers and the same can be said

35:23

about active recall and space repetition

35:25

because so many videos and so many

35:27

people are talking about it because of

35:29

the fact that it's easy because of the

35:31

fact it's popular because of the fact of

35:33

success bias

35:34

because of the fact that this encoding

35:36

related stuff is just not as easy to

35:39

explain in a very short youtube video as

35:41

you can see from this unnecessarily long

35:43

youtube video probably you are led to

35:45

believe that it's more legit and it's

35:47

not your fault it's just the way that

35:49

our brain is wired it's just the

35:51

biological tendency of the human brain

35:52

is that when something is more available

35:55

we think it is more legitimate and this

35:57

has been studied across all different

35:58

fields including you know politics and

36:00

science belief and all of this stuff if

36:02

we see it more we think it's more legit

36:04

and it creates this spiral we get people

36:06

that are learning this from these common

36:08

and popular videos they think it's legit

36:11

they try it the ones that are successful

36:13

feel really confident they make a

36:15

youtube video about it and that becomes

36:17

even more common so it produces this

36:19

sort of spiral of really confident

36:22

people learning something from

36:24

common knowledge then just kind of

36:26

making it more and more and more and

36:28

more common and now it just it seems

36:31

like that's kind of the only way to do

36:32

things but that's actually very

36:33

demoralizing because if that truly is

36:36

the best study technique there is and

36:38

you've tried it and you're not getting

36:39

the result that you want then does that

36:41

mean you're not able to achieve your

36:44

academic goals does that mean you're too

36:46

dumb does it mean that you're just not

36:47

going to be able to do it but that's not

36:49

the case that's not the case so again

36:52

i'm not saying the active record space

36:53

repetition are bad it's a good part of

36:56

your studying system

36:58

but

36:59

if that is the only thing that you're

37:01

relying on and you're not actually

37:03

building good encoding techniques then

37:06

you're essentially just trying to refill

37:08

a bucket with a hole in it obviously the

37:11

best step is to patch that hole to begin

37:13

with now most students really

37:15

underestimate their potential if you're

37:18

already good at encoding

37:20

the chances are that you can actually

37:22

improve that even more

37:24

usually significantly some of the

37:27

students that are coming into my course

37:28

are already getting let's say 90 or in a

37:30

test or an exam or more

37:32

they are increasing their study

37:34

efficiency by two to three times they're

37:36

studying only 50 30 or 50

37:40

of how much they used to study

37:41

beforehand and getting the same grades

37:43

i've got students that are going from

37:45

getting like failing their papers c's

37:47

and d's to getting the top marks in

37:50

their entire cohort and yes it's not

37:52

easy

37:53

no it's not just hey plug in this

37:55

technique and you can just solve all

37:56

your problems it evaporates and you know

37:58

you become you know like a yoda of

38:00

studying it's not like that they are

38:02

working hard and they're developing

38:04

these skills just like you'd have to

38:06

work hard and develop the skills to play

38:07

a musical instrument or to play a sport

38:10

really well same thing is that when you

38:11

really train yourself to use certain

38:13

studying techniques you can actually

38:15

kind of unlock your brain's potential

38:18

which is a super

38:20

cliche thing to say and it makes me

38:22

cringe a little bit to say it but it's

38:23

kind of true so i would say for those of

38:26

you that are feeling super confident

38:28

about

38:29

your study skills right now because you

38:31

feel like you already know all the

38:32

techniques and you know how to use them

38:34

approach things with an open mind um

38:37

you never know maybe if you were to

38:38

study this field for another 20 years

38:40

you might realize that there's more to

38:42

it than you realize it's possible it's

38:44

just it's possible i'm not saying that's

38:46

the case you could be an absolute just

38:48

genius but

38:50

it's possible right it's just it's

38:52

possible like it's worth having an open

38:54

mind about right that's all i'm saying

38:57

or if you're someone that is in the

39:00

situation where you've tried a lot of

39:01

study techniques and hasn't worked for

39:02

you and you're feeling demorally deep

39:04

the more

39:05

demotive no demoralized

39:08

and you're feeling like it's hopeless

39:10

and you don't know whether you can do it

39:13

or you don't think a career is right for

39:15

you because you think you're too dumb or

39:17

it's not within your capacity and other

39:19

study techniques you've tried it and

39:20

tried it and tried it and none of it has

39:22

worked before then this video is really

39:25

for you and i'm here to say that you can

39:27

do it you can train yourself to be

39:30

better and

39:32

you will have to work hard but you're

39:34

probably willing to work hard if you

39:35

know what's going to get you the results

39:37

so

39:38

for you i'd say actually have some hope

39:41

it may be that you've just tried really

39:43

hard at the wrong thing if you want to

39:46

learn more about this then consider

39:48

subscribing anyway if you learned

39:51

something new from this video if you

39:52

found it insightful i'd appreciate if

39:55

you leave a like helps with the

39:56

algorithm all of that sort of stuff i'd

39:58

really be interested for you to leave a

40:00

comment about the things that you want

40:02

me to clarify if there's something that

40:04

you disagree with let's have a

40:05

conversation about this like to mature

40:08

people not saying you suck this is just

40:11

bs

40:12

uh but actually saying hey can you

40:14

clarify on this point because there's a

40:17

lot of explanation and it is pretty deep

40:20

and complex and i wasn't able to cover

40:22

everything so if you've got questions

40:24

check them down below and let's have a

40:26

respectful discussion about it and

40:28

again if you're having this like if

40:30

you're one of the people that's really

40:31

really into active recall and space

40:33

repetition and all the other youtubers

40:35

that you know preach that sort of stuff

40:37

look that's

40:38

up to you it's all good you can

40:41

do whatever you want that's cool you

40:43

know that's fine we don't have to

40:46

we don't have to fight about it right we

40:48

can just be

40:50

open-minded and uh if anyone is

40:53

interested in the real sort of hardcore

40:56

research and theoretical basis for this

40:58

sort of stuff then again leave a comment

41:00

i'm in the middle of currently writing

41:01

up a full report of the research but

41:03

based on the comments from my previous

41:05

videos i've learned that most people

41:06

don't care about the research at all so

41:08

i'm not putting too much of it in this

41:11

video you can check the link for that as

41:13

well and as i said before if you're

41:14

interested in learning sort of

41:15

step-by-step of exactly how to do this

41:17

encoding process how to match that with

41:20

retrieval techniques how to blend it all

41:22

together into a seamless study system

41:23

how to remove your procrastination all

41:25

of that sort of stuff got a full course

41:27

you can check the link in the

41:28

description to just learn a little bit

41:30

more about it see if it's right for you

41:31

anyway thanks for giving me your

41:33

attention for this very long video i

41:35

hope you learned something new and i'll

41:36

catch in the next one

UNLOCK MORE

Sign up free to access premium features

INTERACTIVE VIEWER

Watch the video with synced subtitles, adjustable overlay, and full playback control.

SIGN UP FREE TO UNLOCK

AI SUMMARY

Get an instant AI-generated summary of the video content, key points, and takeaways.

SIGN UP FREE TO UNLOCK

TRANSLATE

Translate the transcript to 100+ languages with one click. Download in any format.

SIGN UP FREE TO UNLOCK

MIND MAP

Visualize the transcript as an interactive mind map. Understand structure at a glance.

SIGN UP FREE TO UNLOCK

CHAT WITH TRANSCRIPT

Ask questions about the video content. Get answers powered by AI directly from the transcript.

SIGN UP FREE TO UNLOCK

GET MORE FROM YOUR TRANSCRIPTS

Sign up for free and unlock interactive viewer, AI summaries, translations, mind maps, and more. No credit card required.